Superman Smashes the Klan

So with recent events spiraling out of control and Asian Americans under attack due to racist actions, it is great to have a story about Superman taking on White Supremacists and taking them down like they deserve. Gene Luen Yang manages to retell a classic Superman serial and Gurihiru does a great job bringing it to life. If you have a kid who wants a great Superman story or you are a grown adult who wants a great Superman story that deals with real life issues that are still being felt today, get this book. Now.

In today's society, racism and bigotry are just as strong and dangerous as it was back then, which is why we need stories that deal with this menace that's both hidden in plain sight and out and about simultaneously, based on the 1940's Superman radio serial that knocked the actual Klu Klux Klan down a peg or ten, "Clan of the Fiery Cross", Superman Smashes The Klan tells a story from two people, Superman who tries to ignore his past but must learn who he is eventually to become the more recognizable hero who has many powers, and Roberta Lee, a young Chinese American girl who moved from Chinatown to Metropolis because of her dad's new job and has to struggle with not only fitting in within her new environment, but also deal with the dangers hidden within the city in the form of the Klan of the Fiery Kross, written by Gene Luen Yang (creator of such works like American Born Chinese and Boxers & Saints) with art by Gurihiru (who worked with Yang on a series of graphic novels set after the acclaimed animated series "Avatar: The Last Airbender") this story is for many people which may be very unsubtle, but it's still very clever and important in today's society

This was a completely different graphic novel to any I have read, particularly because it captures the exact feeling of being an Asian American in America, every character, every situation, every survival and coping technique used to deal with small every day racism and large overt and systematic racism felt honestly too real. Often times I felt deep anger while reading because these are moments that I have dealt with and continue to deal with, however Gene does deftly weave in characters and moments that represent the best of America. I particularly loved the new depth Gene gives to Superman's character as an immigrant. The art style was wonderful and a refreshing look at such an old American Story, I hope to see much more from this Author, as this is the first DC comic I have bought in my life.

Tremendous heart, great message, and in-depth characterization. What’s old is new, as unfortunate as that statement maybe today. A lot of parallels to be drawn for modern times, but told via the context of the past. Still, the message is independent of the timeline, and shows that, while even the strongest is us have doubts, we are all better off respecting and caring for all.

The third act gets a little comic booky, but it's still an incredible ride. There's something wonderful about seeing Clark, Lois, and Jimmy with an actual work dynamic. While it's jarring to see thirties racism through the eyes of an Asian American family, in many ways this is the perfect time for this title to have come out.

Outside of this book, I've only read Dragon Hoops and Avatar by Gene Yang which by far are excellent. I had read reviews on his Superman run w/ JRJR that were really mixed and passed on it. I decided to give this a shot and wasn't disappointed except that they only made this into a junior sized TPB. Wish they did a hardcover or DE as it deserves it. This story is great as it explores the immigrant story of which you have an Asian American family and then Superman. Both of which come from different universes but much of which is the same in integrating into the country. You'll have people that accept you for who you are and are willing to learn and understand and those that don't and never will because of one's uniqueness that differs from they know and are used to. I recommend this story for everyone but more so for Superman fans and the Asian American youth.

In today's lack of mass media, this story won't hit in the same way but I'm glad Gene Luen Yang is able to tell an updated version of this story. As someone who never listened to the original, it's amazing getting to see this very down to earth of a family trying to fit in America intertwined with Superman's own struggle. It's obvious that this story would appeal to me since not being "other" in America is something I've struggled with for a long time. There are bad people and there's a real evil in this that I'm glad they don't look away from. But there's also a real community and cohesion that they focus on more. That, to me, is what the real America is. This book imbues the spirit that make some glad to have found this home. To be in a place with a lot of wrongs but a place where, in this crazy world, a real mix that feels bigger.

What an incredible re-telling of this radio play, suitable for many ages and leads to great conversations about the past and the present. Could not put it down and also loved the backmatter going into details about the history of Superman, the KKK< and the author's own experience in the US.

One of my favorite things about this story is that it centers on Roberta Lee, Tommy's sister, who in the original is not even given a name. She struggles with a "gurgly stomach," whoch means she easily gets motion sickness and also sick from anxiety and stress. She feels like she will never belong outside of Chinatown. But, it is Roberta who finds her voice, who never backs down, who does the most sleuthing, and who even helps Superman own up to some of his own mysteries. She yells at bigots and confronts the leaders of the Klan. Roberta is my hero.

The Superman radio show has, in my opinion, always proven that bigotry and intolerance are not the way to live and this comic more than proves it. A family moving from Chinatown to the metropolis suburbs only to deal with unprovoked attacks from a vicious hate group is shocking to say the least. Perhaps what I find moving is how such characters like Superman and Lois Lane came to the aid of the Lee's without giving it a second thought. This story is just what we need right now, something that shows things like where a person is from or the color of their skin simply don't matter. You should buy this comic, if only to realize that it's wrong to hate just because someone looks different from you.

So with recent events spiraling out of control and Asian Americans under attack due to racist actions, it is great to have a story about Superman taking on White Supremacists and taking them down like they deserve. Gene Luen Yang manages to retell a classic Superman serial and Gurihiru does a great job bringing it to life. If you have a kid who wants a great Superman story or you are a grown adult who wants a great Superman story that deals with real life issues that are still being felt today, get this book. Now.

In today's society, racism and bigotry are just as strong and dangerous as it was back then, which is why we need stories that deal with this menace that's both hidden in plain sight and out and about simultaneously, based on the 1940's Superman radio serial that knocked the actual Klu Klux Klan down a peg or ten, "Clan of the Fiery Cross", Superman Smashes The Klan tells a story from two people, Superman who tries to ignore his past but must learn who he is eventually to become the more recognizable hero who has many powers, and Roberta Lee, a young Chinese American girl who moved from Chinatown to Metropolis because of her dad's new job and has to struggle with not only fitting in within her new environment, but also deal with the dangers hidden within the city in the form of the Klan of the Fiery Kross, written by Gene Luen Yang (creator of such works like American Born Chinese and Boxers & Saints) with art by Gurihiru (who worked with Yang on a series of graphic novels set after the acclaimed animated series "Avatar: The Last Airbender") this story is for many people which may be very unsubtle, but it's still very clever and important in today's society

This was a completely different graphic novel to any I have read, particularly because it captures the exact feeling of being an Asian American in America, every character, every situation, every survival and coping technique used to deal with small every day racism and large overt and systematic racism felt honestly too real. Often times I felt deep anger while reading because these are moments that I have dealt with and continue to deal with, however Gene does deftly weave in characters and moments that represent the best of America. I particularly loved the new depth Gene gives to Superman's character as an immigrant. The art style was wonderful and a refreshing look at such an old American Story, I hope to see much more from this Author, as this is the first DC comic I have bought in my life.

Tremendous heart, great message, and in-depth characterization. What’s old is new, as unfortunate as that statement maybe today. A lot of parallels to be drawn for modern times, but told via the context of the past. Still, the message is independent of the timeline, and shows that, while even the strongest is us have doubts, we are all better off respecting and caring for all.

The third act gets a little comic booky, but it's still an incredible ride. There's something wonderful about seeing Clark, Lois, and Jimmy with an actual work dynamic. While it's jarring to see thirties racism through the eyes of an Asian American family, in many ways this is the perfect time for this title to have come out.

Outside of this book, I've only read Dragon Hoops and Avatar by Gene Yang which by far are excellent. I had read reviews on his Superman run w/ JRJR that were really mixed and passed on it. I decided to give this a shot and wasn't disappointed except that they only made this into a junior sized TPB. Wish they did a hardcover or DE as it deserves it. This story is great as it explores the immigrant story of which you have an Asian American family and then Superman. Both of which come from different universes but much of which is the same in integrating into the country. You'll have people that accept you for who you are and are willing to learn and understand and those that don't and never will because of one's uniqueness that differs from they know and are used to. I recommend this story for everyone but more so for Superman fans and the Asian American youth.

In today's lack of mass media, this story won't hit in the same way but I'm glad Gene Luen Yang is able to tell an updated version of this story. As someone who never listened to the original, it's amazing getting to see this very down to earth of a family trying to fit in America intertwined with Superman's own struggle. It's obvious that this story would appeal to me since not being "other" in America is something I've struggled with for a long time. There are bad people and there's a real evil in this that I'm glad they don't look away from. But there's also a real community and cohesion that they focus on more. That, to me, is what the real America is. This book imbues the spirit that make some glad to have found this home. To be in a place with a lot of wrongs but a place where, in this crazy world, a real mix that feels bigger.

What an incredible re-telling of this radio play, suitable for many ages and leads to great conversations about the past and the present. Could not put it down and also loved the backmatter going into details about the history of Superman, the KKK< and the author's own experience in the US.

One of my favorite things about this story is that it centers on Roberta Lee, Tommy's sister, who in the original is not even given a name. She struggles with a "gurgly stomach," whoch means she easily gets motion sickness and also sick from anxiety and stress. She feels like she will never belong outside of Chinatown. But, it is Roberta who finds her voice, who never backs down, who does the most sleuthing, and who even helps Superman own up to some of his own mysteries. She yells at bigots and confronts the leaders of the Klan. Roberta is my hero.

The Superman radio show has, in my opinion, always proven that bigotry and intolerance are not the way to live and this comic more than proves it. A family moving from Chinatown to the metropolis suburbs only to deal with unprovoked attacks from a vicious hate group is shocking to say the least. Perhaps what I find moving is how such characters like Superman and Lois Lane came to the aid of the Lee's without giving it a second thought. This story is just what we need right now, something that shows things like where a person is from or the color of their skin simply don't matter. You should buy this comic, if only to realize that it's wrong to hate just because someone looks different from you.

This graphic novel is phenomenal. I especially loved the final pages, where author Gene Luen Yang shares personal photos of his family and also recounts the historic events that took place in the United States to both promote and counter racism. As a classroom teacher, I will be ordering multiple copies for my middle grade readers, though I can see 4th and 5th graders also being mature enough to handle this content. I love the way the author makes it easy for readers to see how quickly young minds can be manipulated by fear, and also how he reveals that we all have the power to make individual choices. Yang's characters (as always) are complex, and he honors their humanity in ways few authors are able to. The illustrations are superb. I can't say enough good things about this book....it's incredible.

This is an incredible study on identity, the urge to fit in and the struggle to accept what makes you different. You’d think it’s only about the Chinese family’s tribulations based on the title but it is a Superman story after all. Gene’s integration of those struggles as it pertains to Clark is brilliant. It made me think of the Ezekiel storyline in Spider-man where one question made you rethink Peter’s origin. Superman’s always been my favorite and this story adds another layer to Superman as an inspirational character.

Such a beautiful and touching story. It doesn't shy away from dark and complicated racial issues in America's history. I love that it touches on the experiences faced by multiple minority groups. Despite the darkness, this novel provides the ray of light and positivity we all need right now.

I loved both the art & the timely theme, as well as Superman just learning his powers, in this post WWII tale of racism toward Asian Americans. The anime-inspired art was the perfect medium for this tale. As a fan of the 1945 radio serial, "Superman vs. Atom Man", I felt this was a very creative sequel which expanded on the original's yarn of Superman's on-going fight against fascism.

Superman originally faced race hatred and the Clan of the Fiery Cross in a 16 part story in 1946, this retelling of the story which also has him facing his own alien origins and adding a family of Asian descent is a great re imagining of this still regrettably timely story. Another reminder that white, brown, yellow, whatever we are all AMERICANS!

This was based on an old radio play in which Superman, you guessed it, goes against the KKK. The comic does a great job in it's adapting and I really loved it. I also think it did a good job of showing how kids who are raised around awful, bigoted people can end up changing and learning from their mistakes. If you love Superman, I would recommend this

Kindle requires a review in order to close/complete a book. I am filling in the minimum word count in order to leave.

This reimagining of Superman’s story feels like how I imagine it would sound coming in over the radio in 1946. Granted the tone and tenor have a modern sensibility, but the “feel” is perfect. I imagine you g me huddled near the radio listening to this story unfold. Thoroughly enjoyed it.

I love how the plot revolves around discrimination and acceptance, as those topics very relevant to times like this. I personally identified with this story since I am a first generation immigrant from the Philippines. I love how much this comic highlighted how Superman is also an immigrant who is searching for his place just as much as Asian-Americans are. Despite it focusing on very specific topics, I feel like anyone can read this book because it’s always a joy to see our favorite Daily Planet crew searching for truth and justice.

Good, solid story, with memorable characters and strong ties with the Superman legend. And it does my heart good to see bigotry brought down by the hero in all of us.

Beautifully written, and gorgeously illustrated, Superman Smashes the Klan is the Superman book I have been waiting for. This book belongs in every public library and belongs on middle school reading lists across America.

If only a Superman can fly in and stop racism in its tracks in the real world.... This is a great story rooted in historical events and written by a talented creative mind!

This is a very nicely written story backed up by good artwork. I enjoyed reading this book.

Wonderful book, especially for people who hate racist idiots and love early Superman.

Very good book for kids That shows tactfully the dangers of racism

Gene Luen Yang has got some major talent. I love how he takes an old concept and love of a superhero and makes representation count for everyone.

I’ve read Superman Smashes The Klan and I gotta say, it’s one of the greatest Superman stories ever written! The story, the connection to the realism on how America see people especially minorities and the moral is so beautifully executed. So marvelous and I never get tired of reading this!

A unique amazing Superman story!

An absolutely incredible book, with an amazing lesson. One of the best comics I’ve ever read, and the illustration by Gurihiri are phenomenal.

So good!!! Must (and fun) read for middle & high school! Don't miss the author's note in the back which is half the reason why this book should be required reading.

I bought it for my nephew, he loved it and was very excited to read it (with some assistance, he's 5)

This was so charming and sweet! The art is gorgeous. My one critique is that the Black characters’ designs didn’t feel up to the standard of the rest of the book.

I don't even like DC and especially not Superman but dang I want more of this.

It was great, a great period piece, a great family story and a great Superman story, it’s a must read I loved it

It is the most uplifting and inspiring Superman book of all time!!! Recommended to EVERYONE!!!

This story was originally told during the radio broadcast episodes of Superman during the 1940s. I'm not a die-hard comic fan, and I'm pretty new to the DC fan base. However, Superman has won a high spot in my heart! I devoured this graphic novel from start to finish. The plot moved along flawlessly and even had a steady B plot which impressed me. I thought the characters were diverse and the message was important without being forced. I especially LOVED the 10 pages supplied at the end of the story that shared not only the history of Superman, but US history as well. I learned more about discrimination agains Chinese Americans, the multiple risings of the KKK, the connections between Superman and how the media fought racism in early America, and so much more. After reading that historical context I was even more impressed with Superman Smashes the Klan and how well the story followed historical references. Fantastic book to read for kids, teens, and adults. My 11 year old son gave it 5 stars and he and I had some great conversations about this ugly part of US history. Visit my blog for imagery and a more in depth (spoiler free) review. Thank you DC for providing me a copy of this graphic novel in exchange for an honest review.

SUPERMAN SMASHES THE KLAN is based off of an old radio broadcast from 1946, which featured Superman helping a family of Chinese Americans against the Clan of the Fiery Cross (a stand-in for the Ku Klux Klan). In this book, we follow the Lees, Chinese Americans who have moved from Chinatown to Metropolis after the father, Dr. Lee, has gotten a new job with the Metropolis Health Department. However, not everyone is glad that the family has moved in. Roberta (Lan-shin) is a young girl who is not sure about this move. She always feels a bit awkward around others, and being new in town is tough. She and her brother find a group of children playing baseball and begin to make new friends. However, a lot of them say things that are really racist. Roberta really hates it, but her brother seems to be able to brush it off. One of the boys who said some really horrible things goes home to his uncle, who begins to induct him into the KKK, targeting the Lees, who he felt took his job at the Health Department and his nephew's place on the baseball team. Superman and Inspector William Henderson, who also faces the hate from the KKK as he is black, are there to help. However, the Lees seem to have an unshakable target on their backs, and the KKK begins to really escalate their attacks. At the same time, Superman is confronting his own feeling of being "other" due to his origins. The book includes flashbacks to his childhood and his rejection of his past to better fit in. As he speaks with Roberta and helps the Lees, he begins to accept his own origins and abilities. What I loved: This is really a well fleshed out comic- we have backstory for Superman and a great main character in Lan-shin (Roberta). The racism here is pervasive and presented in a way that makes it clear how awful and threatening it is. Even the scenes where it seems less violent, such as the things the other children say to group all Chinese Americans into one group, come across as clearly wrong, and I really appreciated that these microaggressions are shown alongside the more violent racist events to give the full spectrum. The illustrations here are really fantastic and suit the story perfectly, with the right amount of speech and narrative text to keep the comic on-track and easy to understand/follow. I also really enjoyed the glimpses into Superman's own past that really make this story three-dimensional, and I appreciated the focus on Roberta as a main character- through her eyes, we can see a lot. The end of the book also contains some great explanations about the making of the story, historical context, and the author's own past that is really fascinating, and I am so glad it was added to the book. It really adds so much to the story and informs readers who may not be aware of the full context and it also brings up how far we still have to go when facing intolerance in the present day. Final verdict: A thought-provoking and fantastically composed graphic novel, SUPERMAN SMASHES THE KLAN is a great look at racism and the need for social activism. Please note that I received a review copy. All opinions are my own.

One reason that I like Gene Luen Yang so much as a writer is that he is both entertaining and informative. It is clear in his writing that he loves history and he can bring it to life in his graphic novels. Another nice touch is how he talks about history at the end of his graphic novels, giving the reader background and context to the story. He even provides some of his references, so you can read and learn more if you wish. It adds a deeper element to his works and helped to make this story about Superman even more interesting. Superman Smashes the Klan is actually inspired by the early radio show “The Adventures of Superman” and in 1946 saw Superman take on the Klan of the Fiery Cross (a group heavily inspired by the KKK) and the story helped to destabilize them. In the original, Superman works with a Chinese-American family to thwart the Klan of the Fiery Cross’ plans and to promote tolerance and acceptance. This story follows the same broad outline but brings welcome depth to the characters and dimension to the story. Despite the fact that this is a Superman story, I felt that Roberta was the main character. I was intrigued by her life, struggles, and tenacity. Superman (and Clark Kent) felt more like a side character to Roberta when she was sticking up for herself or trying to stop the bad guys with Jimmy Olsen or her brother, Tommy. I loved getting a look into her life and her family, as everyone struggled and coped with moving from Chinatown to the main part of Metropolis in their own way. It felt authentic and really helped you to connect with the characters. Overall, I thought this was a great superhero story that would appeal to people with an interest in history or books with strong characters, even if they don’t usually gravitate to graphic novels about superpowered people. The digital version of this graphic novel was provided to me by DC Ink, but that does not affect my review in any way.

In 1946, the Adventures of Superman radio show had a story titled “Clan of the Fiery Cross,” as our hero took on a group of White Supremacists across 16 episodes. That story is what inspired this Young Adults collection, Superman Smashes the Klan- which consists of the three-issue mini-series that tackles the all too real threat of bigotry and hate in real life. From writer Gene Luen Yang and the art team Gurihiru, we get a fantastic story that harkens back to Superman’s days of leaping tall buildings in a single bound. Set in 1946, Superman is operating at a lower power level- he doesn’t fly; he doesn’t use his heat vision- but for a reason. At the same time, Dr. Lee and his family move from Chinatown to Metropolis, a big enough adjustment as it is. Being Chinese American unfortunately makes them a target to some of the small-minded residents, and puts the family on the radar of the Klan. The story focuses on Lee’s kids, Tommy and Roberta, as they both try to fit into their new home in their own ways. But when the Klan strikes with a massive burning cross on the front lawn of the Lee’s household, it attacks the police, and a few very well known reporters; Lois Lane, Jimmy Olsen, and Clark Kent. Of course, the other focus is on big blue himself, Superman, who is going through some changes of his own as he starts to find himself and realize that being yourself is ok. Yang’s story is fantastic: a real throwback to the Superman of yesteryear and a shining example of how to take a stand against hate. The Lee family’s struggles run parallel to Superman in a way and creates a bond between Superman and the Lee children. Sometimes the strongest ones are the smallest ones, the quietest ones, and Superman sees that firsthand. I have loved Gurihiru’s artwork since their days at Marvel, but this book takes the cake. The clean linework, the animated feel to it all: it is impressive to see. I love that this story takes place in the ’40s, as we see that world visually represented so well here, right down to the “S” on Superman’s chest and the designs of Superman’s Kryptonian parents. The artwork is stunning, and fits so well with this story: from the lighthearted moments to the pulse-pounding sequences- everything looks and feels fantastic. You might be thinking: “but it’s a young adult book, can I, a fully grown person, enjoy this?” The answer is a loud and factual YES! Superman Smashes the Klan is a book I would not imagine to be for young adults, as the topic of racism is always dark. But it is also very real, and this book does a fantastic job tackling the issue. I highly recommend Superman Smashes the Klan: whether you are a Superman fan, superhero fan in general, or just love a good story- this one is for you.

I received a copy of this book for free from the publisher (DC Comics) in exchange for an honest review. This book was SO GOOD! I loved it. So first off, the artwork is adorable. It worked really well. I love that the story did not shy away from depicting racism. It shows both the hard core racism of the Klan and the more casual racism of Tommy and Roberta’s friends. I also liked that the book had an even blend of Tommy and Roberta’s story and Superman’s story. Both storylines were well developed and engaging. They also paralleled each other nicely. What I really loved about Superman’s story was how human he was. Like yes he is a superhero with powers, but at his core he is just like us. One of my favorite parts of the book happens in the beginning after the Klan burns a cross in the Lee’s front yard. 3 African American men come to help but Mr. Lee doesn’t want it. One of the men says, “They don’t want us around, not even when their house is on fire.” The other African American man (who is the police inspector) replies, “They got a burning cross on their lawn, don’t they? For tonight, at least, they are us. Even if they don’t want to admit it” (pg 48). This small part left a big impact on me because it shows a hint of the anti-blackness that is sometimes seen in the Asian American community. But it also shows a solidarity. That even though they are different races, they still face similar struggles. They are not as different as they may think. At the end of the book, there is an essay by the author, “Superman and Me.” The essay gives the historical background behind the story. I really loved it. It not only explained the history of the KKK and racism in the America, but also the story of Superman and how he came to be. Overall, I really recommend this graphic novel. Its message is an important one, especially in today’s times.

I received an advanced copy of Superman Smashes the Klan from Netgalley, so I could share my review with you! The Lee family has just moved to Metropolis from Chinatown, but not everyone is ready to welcome them to the neighborhood. Immediately upon their arrival, they become targets of the notorious Klan, who want to prevent non-white people from living and working in the same neighborhoods as them. Roberta Lee struggles to adjust to her new life in Metropolis, but her brother seems to easily fit in with the new crowd. As the Klan threat becomes more serious, Roberta worries about her families safety, wondering if they will ever feel welcome in Metropolis. The Lees aren’t alone in their fight, however, and one Super ally might be enough to turn the tide! You can get your copy of Superman Smashes the Klan on May 12th from DC Comics! Many people choose to forget Superman’s position as an outsider: quite literally an alien, created by two Jewish boys just before the start of WWII. Superman Smashes the Klan goes back to the symbolic roots of Superman, creating a firm statement on what his purpose, both historically and today. Based on a radio broadcast of a similar story, this graphic novel brings Superman’s fight against xenophobia into vibrant color! I loved the way the story, written by Gene Luen Yang, blended Superman’s personal struggles with the similar struggles being faced by the Lee family. This story hit right into the heart of what Superman is supposed to stand for: Hope. My Recommendation- If you wish that your superhero comics had a stance on issues that are relevant to today, I strongly recommend reading Superman Smashes the Klan! This book weaves together classic superhero narratives with hard hitting topics, making it one of the most impactful comics I have read in a long time!

This graphic novel really has it all. History, action, and the icon that is Superman. The story starts when the Lee family moves out of Metropolis’s Chinatown and into a ‘regular’ neighborhood. Unfortunately, this catches the eye of the bigots in the Ku Klux Klan. While the father, Dr. Lee, adjusts to his new position in the city’s health department, his children Roberta and Tommy find themselves at the front lines of racism in post-WW2 Metropolis. Superman opens up the great novel with punching out a villain of his own: a leftover super Nazi named Mr. Atom. Yet, in this action he finds is found one of Superman’s rare weaknesses, a metal that takes away his strength. This leads him to more discoveries about his backstory because in this book he isn’t aware of much of his mythos. There is an internal conflict between the life the Kent’s have set forth for him and the aliens who start to appear to Superman during the course of the book. He’s scared and unsure of their purpose. Yes, the artwork is fulfilling. Yes, the pacing is perfect. Yes, the juxtaposition between Superman’s alienness and the Lees as “other” provides a depth that just sucks you in. But the part that did it for me was Yang’s essay at the end of the book about his connection to Superman. It tells the story of the original legacy of his fight against bigotry and how Yang chose to update the story while still holding true to the roots of history, style, and diction. Superman Smashes the Klan is broken up into three part and at just under 250 pages, this is a book where you can truly follow complete arcs of many of the characters. I’d love for this book to be in my school’s library and I will be recommending to my students as well as my history teacher friends. I see a huge audience for this wonderful graphic novel. 4.5 out of 5 stars.

After defeating a Kryptonite-powered Nazi bad guy who apparently doesn't realize World War II is over, Superman becomes more curious about his origins, especially why the green rock powering the villain made him sick. Ma and Pa Kent didn't tell Clark his whole history with them but they left enough clues. Superman eventually discovers recordings from his Kryptonian parents, who help him to understand his powers and his purpose on Earth. At the same time, the Lee family moves from the Chinatown neighborhood to Metropolis (or at least a suburban part of the city). Dr. Lee has a new job with the Metropolis Health Department where he experiences both openness and racism from his co-workers. The focus of the story is on the Lee children, Tommy and Roberta, who try to fit in to their new neighborhood. They go to the local youth rec center where Tommy easily fits in. Roberta has a much harder time. The family runs into a bigger problem when the Klan of the Fiery Kross burns a cross in their yard. Reporters from The Daily Planet cover the incident, drawing Superman into the fight against the Klan. Yang based this story on a multi-part story from The Adventures of Superman radio show in the late 1940s. The show was a big hit and a big black-eye for the popularity of the Ku Klux Klan. This kid-friendly version of the story still delivers both an exciting story and a timely message, since racism has not gone away. The characters are not one-dimensional, not even the bad guys. Paralleling the Lee family immigrant story with Superman's exploration of his own immigrant nature seems obvious but is delivered in a more subtle and convincing way. Nice moments of comedy and nods to changes in Superman's mythology through the years make the book very enjoyable for even a seasoned fan of the Man of Steel. Recommended.

Back in 2016, I read the book "Superman Versus The Ku Klux Klan: The True Story of How the Iconic Superhero Battled the Men of Hate," and thought that this true history surrounding a radio show was absolutely fascinating. I wished that I could read the story, and earlier this year, I could have passed out with joy when I learned that Gene Luen Yang had created a graphic novel based on it. This is everything that I could have hoped for. I love the 1946 period details, the similarity to the original radio show episode, the messages about immigration and Chinese-American experiences, and the poignant flashbacks related to Clark Kent's childhood and his process of recognizing and admitting that he is an alien. The Superman story parallels extremely well with the primary narrative about Tommy and Roberta's experiences dealing with hatred from the KKK and the casual, often unintended racism of their peers, and this was very nuanced and interesting. The book also includes a significant amount of history and clarity related to Klan operations and dynamics. This is a fantastic, engaging science fiction story, and it is also great historical fiction. I enjoyed it tremendously, and also loved the author's note at the end, which shares about his experiences as a Chinese American and covers the histories of Superman's creation, Chinese immigration, and the KKK with economical word count and remarkable clarity. I was particularly impressed with how well he handled the different nuances and conditions around resurgences of the Klan in different locations and time periods. This was very well done, and I am impressed with this as both a top-notch adventure story and an educational resource.

I don't know that I've ever been so moved by a comic before. Superman Smashes the Klan is easily one of the best pieces of literature I've read in 2020. It's timely, emotional, fun, so important and so well done. The material is presented in a way that will be so easy for kids to take in and process, and it tells a story that kids need to hear. This is a comic that I'll be screaming about for a long time. Superman has always been my favorite comic character. And I love his presentation in this comic. Not edgy, not anything new, he's just Superman as we know and love him. But the real stars of this story are Roberta and Tommy. Roberta is a fantastic main character(I especially love that she is front and center here because in the original radio show she was a side character who DIDN'T EVEN HAVE A NAME). Roberta embodies the awkwardness and strength that I see in so many young girls, and the fact that she's as much of a hero as the Man of Steel himself is just fantastic. The art in Superman Smashes the Klan is just as good as the story itself. It's clear, almost cute, and definitely evokes a classic Superman feel. I thought that the facial expressions were so well done, and they definitely added a real layer of emotion. I absolutely loved this comic. It's full of snappy dialogue, wonderful characters, strong messages, and was just fun to read. I'll be continuously recommending it to comic fans, Superman fans, anyone looking for diverse reads, and really just anyone I can get to read it. Superman Smashes the Klan is a story I'll definitely revisit over and over, and I have no doubts that it will continue to be a favorite of mine.

I'm so grateful for the chance I had to read and review this wonderful graphic novel! I was up half the night reading it—I couldn't get enough! Quick Thoughts -The art is so fun! The bright colors and emotion-filled characters was so eye-catching and fun to read. It felt like classic Superman art that will appeal to present-day kids. -Roberta's relationship with her brother and parents felt really realistic to me—sometimes there are communication issues, sometimes they don't all have the same pov—but the love shown for each family member was warm and beautiful. -The addition of a secondary character whose uncle is head of the Klan was interesting, and I loved how his character arc developed alongside Roberta and Tommy. Lasting Impressions I loved that this book includes recognizable characters such as Lois Lane, Jimmy Olsen, and others, as well as includes new characters such as Roberta and Tommy Lee. I became immediately attached to Roberta and her journey as she learned to stand up for herself and do what's right even if it's hard. I loved how the author portrayed her anxiety. I believe a lot of kids will relate to her. The depictions of familiar characters are pretty classic, such as Lois Lane's wit and in-your-business attitude—it made me love her even more. The depiction of Superman in this story is poignant, in that it treats Superman as an immigrant from his home planet to Earth. I've never thought about this connection before. He struggles to come to terms that he isn't just MORE than human, but that he isn't human at all. Seeing Roberta help him accept himself was so sweet—I loved their friendship. There are some scary depictions of things that the Klan of the Fiery Kross does, but I don't think it would be too much for kids. In fact, I think it will bring about healthy discussions about racism in families that are understandable for kids. This story is based on a radio serial from the 1940s, which I didn't know until after I'd read the book. The back of the book includes an author's note with history about Superman, history about racism in the USA before and after the 1940s, and some snippets of his own childhood when he dealt with racism. It was insightful and a welcome addition to the graphic novel. Overall Feelings I loved this book. A lot. Even after this review, I can't quite put into words how much I enjoyed this book. It's message is powerful and beautiful. I'll definitely be purchasing this book and recommending it to anyone and everyone.

It is 1946 when Tommy and his family move from Chinatown to Downtown Metropolis. Their dad is excited about his new job at the Metropolis Health Department, but Roberta and Tommy are reluctant to make the change. The only thing that makes the move worth it is the fact that Superman will be nearby. Tommy quickly makes friends, but Roberta feels like the odd man out. While the Lee family is trying to learn about their new lives, the Klan of the Fiery Kross has targeted them as their next mission. It starts with a burning cross in front of their house and then moves on to Tommy being kidnaped. The Klan is looking for bigger targets too as it moves its focus to the Daily Planet and the Unity House, a local youth club. What adventures will Tommy and Roberts have with Superman? What truths will Superman learn about himself and his history? Superman Smashes the Klan is a compilation of the first three serials with the same title. This story was originally published in the ’40s as a radio broadcast that shook America. I was not familiar with this storyline for Superman and fully enjoyed learning a little bit of Superman folklore along the way. This book is being promoted for middle school readers, but I think young adults and adults alike will have a good escape while turning the pages. A great read for all graphic novel and Superman fans.

Superman Smashes the Klan! And he's been doing so for about 75 years. The Man of Steel first encountered the KKK in his very own radio show in the 1940's. It seems that every generation or so, DC Comics publishes a story dedicated to Superman fighting either the Ku Klux Klan directly or some group that was indirectly inspired by what the Klan represents. In that way, Superman has never completely lost that sense of truth and justice that Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster gave to their character. He has always remained something of a social crusader. It began in 1946. The Anti Defamation League had infiltrated the KKK. The ADL contacted the Superman radio show and suggested that they feature a story where the titular hero faces the Klan. Over 16 episodes, from June to July of '46, "Clan of the Fiery Cross" aired and Superman took his war to the fascist menace. And as for the comic? Well, this story is a new take on the saga that is the "Clan of the Fiery Cross." In the 3-part miniseries, written by Gene Luen Yang with art by Gurihiru, Superman is in his younger days. He helps an immigrant family, battles racists, and finds himself grappling with life as an alien outsider. Like the radio show from which it drew inspiration, the story takes place in 1946. The story is brisk and the art is cartoony. This one feels very inspired by the Golden Age of Comic Books. It's also very topical, considering the times we live in. What I like most about this story is that it squarely defines the KKK and their sympathizers as the enemy. Superman has some of that hutzpah, here, that he had in his earliest days. The Champion of the Oppressed has returned and... if there was ever a time for him... the time is now! Thanks, Superman, for fighting fascism and taking it to these bad guys! I recommend this for all ages as a way to get little ones engaged in the causes of social justice!

I didn't know that Superman had fought the Ku Klux Klan in some of the original radio shows. (In the original and this book they rename them to the Klan of the Fiery Cross. I have nothing against Superman fighting racism, but I thought it might seem tacky or preachy. I'm really happy to say it's an engrossing story, great art, and something both I and my kids enjoyed. It's terrific artwork in a full color book. It feels a little retro but modern at the same time. The action is really well scripted and I had no issues following it. It's easy to keep the characters straight and they're drawn right every time. The panels and flow is really good. It's not awe-inspiring artwork, but it's beyond well-done in that I don't even have any flaws to pick at. The story is great too. It has superman realizing his powers, but in a different way than I've seen before. It takes some of the old ideas like Superman running on telephone poles, and it makes it all feel new again. Superman's internal struggles give him a human side that can be hard to portray in an invincible superhero. The main villain's are pretty one-deminsional, but one of the secondary villians sees character development and growth. The kids that are the main characters have real struggles even if things about always go exactly right in the end. It's a feel good Hollywood ending kind of story, but it's done well. This has what the new superman movies don't have. It has enough action without overdoing it. It has a great story. It has really good art. Then it also has a story standing against racism. I totally suggest this!

I love the Fleisher Studios Superman caroons (they did, in truth, bankrupt them) because the Siegel/Shuster style was never stronger. Picking up all of that, including the original black and red S, here is a modern take with great respect to the 1940s character as well as adapting an early Superman serial fighting white-robed bad guys. Here is the Klan in 1946 as a Chinese family moves to Metropolis and gets a burning cross on their lawn. When reporters Lois Lane and Clark Kent investigate, it's a graphic novel (collecting issues 1-3 of the story... but there's more to come) not only does the Man of Steel come to their rescue(s) but begins to discover his own abilities (flying! Heat vision!) and even the phantoms of his alien parents following him. Bestselling author Gene Luen Yang supplies a loving homage to the then-evolving superhero while artist Gurihiru brings the clean line work of near-manga animation to make it visually, well, super. As a boy, see young Clark discovering his powers; see a young Lois become the strong-willed reporter with more apparent drive then Clark Kent. As Superman gives his cape to a frightened child, from an alien who knows what it feels like to be outside the middle-class white status quo, a deadly green something is revealed that makes Superman weak, sick and scared. WE know what it is, but here it comes to this Golden Age hero for the first time(s). My press review edition has pages of pencils to conclude the saga. It's an added "wow" to reading a superb work, right down to the artist's non-colored outstanding work. From Ma Kent sewing on Clark's S to the superhero emerging from Smallville teen in an act of bravery to climbing a skyscraper, this is a wonderful opportunity to FEEL what this legendary character was in his earliest days... but never fully realized as accurately until now. Kids will love it; so will old readers who good from great. This is GREAT. Bravo DC!

I was familiar with the "Clan of the Fiery Cross" episodes of the old Superman radio show, and the devastating impact they had on the prominence and influence of the KKK in the late 1940s. I thought it was a swell idea to adapt that to a YA graphic novel, but I was not prepared for how wonderfully clever, nuanced and thoughtful it would be. A lot of ground has been covered with the Superman-as-immigrant metaphor, but juxtaposing Superman's experiences navigating his new world with a Chinese American family as they move from Chinatown to Metropolis, and seeing them both try to acclimate to their new environment, was a great idea by author Gene Luen Yang. I appreciated that the book didn't shy away from the ugliness of bigotry, as young readers need to understand what this evil really looks like. That said, the Clan members are not simple one-note cartoon characters. Yang invests them with just the right amount of humanity and pathos, and shows how ignorance and fear leads to hatred and how it can be passed down to generations, and most importantly, how younger generations can break the cycle of hate. At first, the heavily manga influenced artwork was a little jarring to me, but I ultimately came to enjoy it, as the draftsmanship and storytelling are top notch. I can't think of a better superhero story for the time we're in right now.

Superman faces off against Atom Man at the Metropolis dam, and Atom Man is surprisingly strong! Superman rings Atom Man's bells, and finds a strange glowing green rock there, which weakens him. Superman isn't sure why he feels so...well, human all of a sudden, or why he's seeing strange phantoms that keep trying to speak to him. Meanwhile, the Lee family is moving from Chinatown to downtown Metropolis. Their daughter, Lan-Shin (though after the move her family calls her Roberta), is a bright girl who's awkward around other people, and her brother Tommy just wants to play baseball and fit in. Life seems good after moving in, though one of the early visitors is underhandedly rude, and the Lee family begins to settle into their new life. However, Tommy upsets one of the kids he meets, and that leads to the Klan of the Fiery Kross showing up at the Lee's house and burning a giant cross in their front yard. To make matters worse, one of the Klan members throws a molotov cocktail toward their home! Will the Lees be able to deal with this newfound racism as they build a life in Metropolis? Will Superman help them, and what is going on with his strange visions? I have so many ways I want to praise this graphic novel, simply because of how well it exemplifies what a story about a superhero should be, particularly for youth (though adults will also love this story). A superhero taking the fight to racists, what's not to like here? This book showcases both outright and overt racism in realistic, dramatic ways, and I really appreciated how well the author nailed this part across a variety of characters and situations. This book packs a lot into its pages, the artwork is excellent, some beautiful panels even span two pages seamlessly, and there are many touching moments that have real impact. The characters act like real people, even Superman himself, and I really appreciated how even the smaller characters contributed in great ways to the story. With the story covering big swathes of Superman's backstory, his origins, and even his own internal complexes, I really liked seeing a rooted Superman who deals with his own mental blocks on his way to becoming a better superhero. Even the villains of the story are relatively well developed, and they also behave just like real people would, even when they're being vile. This graphic novel is based on a very popular 16-part storyline from the radio show called The Adventures of Superman that aired in 1946, and that storyline was called "The Clan of the Fiery Cross." I think that Gene Luen Yang has done a phenomenal job of refreshing this story for modern audiences, and I thoroughly enjoyed it from start to finish. There's even a personal article written by him at the end that describes some of the history of Superman mixed with US history, and his own reasons for writing this graphic novel. Go now, leap whatever buildings you must, stop whatever locomotives are necessary, and fly to buy this book today. Scratch that, buy two and give one to somebody you love, so that they too can enjoy a beautifully drawn and written story with a moral heart of gold.

A Chinese family, the Lees moves from Chinatown to a suburb of Metropolis. As they are unpacking the boxes, racial remarks are made. The neighbors help the family by taking their boxes into the house. Tommy and Roberta, his younger sister go to the Unity House. Tommy joins the baseball team as pitcher. The original pitcher Chuck quits and calls Tommy and Roberta “Wontons.” Tommy is still in the team as pitcher and makes friends. Roberta tries to be invisible. The “Klan of the Firey Kross” visits their home where they plant a burning cross while threatening them. Later when Tommy and Robert go home from their school, they split up. As Tommy is walking home, he stops to see if a driver needs help and is kidnapped. The leader of the Klan has decided that Tommy will “pay” for getting his group arrested. Roberta gets Superman to help as Tommy has not gotten home for several hours. Superman comes to the rescue. Superman is having a crisis, he is hearing voices and seeings things. He doesn’t know who he is or who his original parents were. Will Superman be okay? Will Tommy’s family move back to Chinatown? The police lieutenant is an Afro-American who helps Tommy get to the hospital as Superman thinks Tommy’s arm is broken. When he asks the policeman under him why he wouldn’t do something with a racial slur, he arrests the policeman. There was a radio show in the 1940s “The Adventures of Superman,” that did a series on the Ku Klax Klan. Due to fear of retribution, it was named “The Klan of the Firey Kross.” Superman has discover that he is an alien. The Lee family must decide how to deal with racial slurs and treatment. The art is well done. It has you see the cars and homes of the 1940s America. The author has written an interesting essay about his family and their personal experiences. He also gives background on the Ku Klux Klan and the impact of Superman’s stand against them. It impacted America. There is a bibliography included. Disclaimer: I received an arc of this book from the author/publisher from NetGalley. I wasn’t obligated to write a favorable review or any review at all. The opinions expressed are strictly my own.

Superman Smashes the Klan is a great introduction to Superman for young readers who are fans of Gene Luen Yang but may have never read Superman in comic book form. Based on a plot line from the 1940's Superman radio serial, Superman Smashes the Klan follows the travails of a Chinese-American family who encounter racism when they move into a white neighborhood, ultimately becoming enmeshed with a KKK-type organization. The story provides a backstory for Superman, as well as explaining how he ramped up his powers (going from leaping very high to actually flying, learning to use his x-ray vision, etc.). In this 1940's version, Jimmy Olson is a young teen, Clark Kent actually does some reporting and kids go to afternoon matinees and play baseball. I'm not familiar with the radio serial, but the plot adheres to it somewhat according to Yang's notes in the back of the book. The art is a mixture of anime/manga (oversized eyes/speed lines) and classic 1940's/50's comics storytelling. The colors are bright, the heroes and villains are sharply outlined and the young reader will learn some valuable lessons about racism in postwar America. If the readers become fans of superhero comics as a result, so much the better. Highly recommended.

While this comic portrays a historical account of the hatred and activities of the Klan in the mid-1940s, alot of the racist elements are so relevant to today’s events. Due to the current popularity of graphic novel amongst kids, this will be a comic that they will enjoy reading and also be exposed to some historical fiction as well. The drawings are more current day, almost like anime, but still have that classic comic presentation to it. It was really interesting to find out that this comic was based upon an actual radio broadcast of the show Superman. I especially appreciated the historical account and personalization of the story written by Gene Luen Yang at the end of the book. I learned interesting facts about the Chinese American Immigrants in the U.S. and also about the Ku Klux Klan. This book is definitely a way for kids to be exposed about the history of racism in this country through a graphic comic.

It's amazing all the synchronicity we've seen the last few months, with stories in every medium reflecting our current issues, even though they were created shortly before the novel corona virus and other events. This is one like that. Superman faces the KKK alongside a persecuted Chinese family, which is quite timely. This could have been specifically written for today, but is really a retelling of an old Superman radio show story. When Superman first appeared in Action Comics No. 1, he saved an innocent person from execution and dealt with domestic violence. Early on, Superman faced real issues, including war profiteering, before eventually conforming to the stereotypical hero vs. super villain plots. This comic is written in that early mode. It starts with fighting a Nazi villain who has a powered armor suit, so the connection is made between Nazis and White Supremacy. Despite a serious topic, it is handled in a way that children can enjoy (as well as adult fans of classic comics). I wholly recommend it!

Thank you NetGalley and DC Comics for sharing this eARC in exchange for an honest review. Graphic novels are always a hit in my classroom and Gene Luen Yang is known for writing gripping, thought-provoking, and suspenseful stories. But this one, this one is unique and powerful. It is a superhero comic, which will engage and entertain my sixth graders, but it also tells a very important story that was first broadcast in the 1940s, but is now in print. It tells about a Chinese American family, the Lees, who was moved from Chinatown to downtown Metropolis, but their welcoming is less than warm. The Ku Klux Klan begin targeting the Lee family and even kidnap Tommy, the oldest boy. Along with Superman battling the Klan and saving Tommy, there also emerges a story of identity and learning to accept and embrace what sets you apart from others. This book also has some origin story in it with Superman. All in all, a fantastic and important story that I cannot wait to have in my classroom.

This is an excellent read so far and very easy to get into. There is a lot of information packed into it and I am looking forward to finishing this book and will update once I get to the end of it. Update: There are lots of stereotypes and racial slurs that would be necessary to explain to kids unfamiliar with some of the slurs. And...a young boy struggles with his identity and the choice to join the Klan with his uncle or to expose the Klan to the cops. He tries to walk middle ground for a while to maintain family ties while also not hurting a Chinese family. It also deals with middle grade issues of fitting in. This is complicated for a main character, Roberta, who realizes her memories of life before she moved had become sugar-coated from her present feelings of exclusion. This is an interesting concept to explore from the perspective of a middle grade student who has changed schools several times. Realizing how someone in this situation would view previous schools vs a current school situation (not a quarantine homeschool) is critical to understanding and mentoring middle school kids effectively. The book is very interesting including critical periods of decision making as he wrestles with confusion about what to do and what he's even thinking. Excellent and timely graphic novel. I'm now giving it 5 stars.

[I received an electronic review copy of this from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.] This was excellent! The story, the characters, the art work. I loved all of it. The story is meaty and rich. It's not just about the racism and Superman saving the day. There's an identity piece of the story for Roberta and even more for Superman. It's also a friendship story as the Lees try to adjust to a new community. The racism piece had several layers to it as well. I was so impressed by how much was covered in this story. This didn't feel like a one-and-done read to me. I would read this again and probably discover more nuances than I did the first time through. I continue to be impressed with the work DC Entertainment has been doing in the last year on graphic novels for kids and teens. Highly recommend!

So very timely! The title instantly caught my eye and I knew I had to read this. This was based on a 16 episode story ark from the forties that showcased Superman taking down the "Clan of the Fiery Cross" on the radio show. It was immensely popular at the time and is credited with stopping a third wave of KKK "power." The story is about a Chinese family who moves to Metropolis and are instantly targeted by the Klan and get a burning cross in their yard. The children are dejected but with the help of Lois Lane, some neighborhood kids, and Superman - they begin to feel their confidence return. Really well done and addresses lots of key racist ideologies. I really liked that at the end of the graphic novel there is a little essay with pictures talking about the origins of the comic and the history. Really well done!

This isn't your typical Superman fights the evil, mad scientist genius type of story. This is a story that touches on a serious subject and serious issue of racism. The story is set in 1946 and it's about an Asian family that moves out of Chinatown into Metropolis. This does not sit well with the local group of white supremacists which call themselves the Klan of the First Cross. This is a story about how the Lees, the local law enforcement and Superman deal with this group that has set it's sights on the Lees. I feel like this is a subject matter that needs to be discussed in this genre. Not just the usual German Nazis but American neo nazis. I was impressed with how this story approached racism not just the obvious and often talked about racism with nazis but also the Asian racism towards African Americans, something that isn't as openly depicted or discussed. This is a story that will get people talking and it may even make some people uncomfortable. That's a good thing, maybe it will lead to some inner reflection. The illustrations are amazing and are what one would have come to expect from a Superman comic. I did not just enjoy this story, I really appreciated every aspect of it.

Superman Smashes the Klan is another fine example of graphic novel composing by Gene Luen Yang. Yang was the National Ambassador for Young People's Literature a few years back, and his expertise as a visual storyteller is always wonderful. In this book, Yang takes an idea that was explored decades ago, combines this inspiration with a fresh vision of a popular character, and shares a story that is timely and would make an ideal addition to classroom shelves, school libraries, and personal collections for younger and older readers. The art is stylish and captures the reader's eye, almost in an animated flourish. This glossy surface goes a long way in delivering a story that inspires thought and, hopefully, action for the better. Highly recommended.

The graphics blend well with the easy to read presentation of Superman and the Lee family vs. the Klan. Both enjoying and making its social points the artwork is in color the first half of the book and black and white in the rest. Gene Luen Yang has a solid career in advocating reading for the young and appearing as a finalist in several young people's book competitions as a finalist. He has also won some prestigious awards for his writing. The artwork is nicely softer than a lot of the contemporary sharp edged art. Great on the brain and eyes-easy flow. The story takes place in 1946 and is well conceived. And its nice to see how the Lee family (of Chinese extraction) partner up with Superman to take down the Klan. This is a personal retelling of the Lees and Superman smashing the Klan. Different and interesting.

This was written recently, but set in the past, and written in the style Superman was ‘presented’ at that time, by that I mean, for instance, Superman ran across power lines and did a few things I don’t recall seeing him doing before... but a few decades before I picked up my first Superman, or even DC Comic, was commonplace behavior for him. There was a time when all stories, particularly those aimed at kids, had a moral to the story, taught a lesson, and if we were lucky gave kids something to think about. This harkens back to those days of quality storytelling, unfortunately reminding us that some of the problems we are facing aren’t new, but we are strong enough to tackle them, together.

Superman Smashes the Klan is a fascinating work. Based on a radio drama from the 1940s, the graphic novel has Superman taking on a stand-in for the Ku Klux Klan. To me, what works the best about Superman Smashes the Klan is how it manages to sidestep the largest problem that people have with Superman comics, the fact that he’s "unrelatable." By tying in a story about xenophobia, Yang is able to tell a more personal character arc about Superman accepting his Kryptonian Heritage. Clark's story is then mirrored by a young Chinese girl who finds her family the target of the KKK. Add in Gene Luen Yang's appealing art style, and you have a graphic novel that's strong all around. Highly recommended.

I am a long time comic fan, long time. My older cousin use to give me bags of comics back in the day, back then they sold for 25 cents. Yes it's been a long time. Found memories of reading them all. So I was more than happy to get this one in my hands. This one is very done with quality drawings and good color. A joy to read and look at. I have not read many comics lately, so it's nice to get back into them and this one has a great story that is told well. Refreshing to have a story that should be told so maybe a younger generation can build a better character. One thing, the last, almost half is black and white line drawings with some colored wording. I like it, but some people might not. Just a FYI. Overall, real happy with this book and it's priced pretty good for a graphic novel. Would happily recommend.

I got a review copy on a whim, so I'm not the primary audience - nevertheless, I found this an interesting and culturally-relevant Superman take. It presents a new version of the well-trod origin tale, so a longtime Superman fan will have to forget things again. But for kids, and that is the audience, they will only vaguely know where Superman came from. The story is solid - not that deep or groundbreaking, but a good book with a story of tolerance and doing the right thing. If the enemies are totally one-dimensional, that's a necessary trade in comic books. The art leans toward manga and anime, and I found it easy on the eyes and designed to present the story in an attractive, non-distracting way. For a young reader, this would be a good introduction to Superman, and the idea of being on the right side.

What a tremendous book! Gene Luen Yang and Gurihiru deliver a stellar and poignant look at Superman dealing with his identity. That being said, the star of the book is Roberta (Lan-Shin) and how she deals with moving from Chinatown and the racism (both subtle and overt) that she deals with. She and her family are new to Metropolis and all deal with the move differently. Things turn on their head when the Klan shows up. Superman and the Lee's are now forced to defend themselves. The book is smart, sweet, and timely. Its billed as something for middle grades but everyone can benefit from this. There is so much heart in this book. Overall, perfection.

This is another new graphic novel from DC. They are really on it last few months. I'm having a blast reading these on my Kindle Fire. It took a bit of trial and error, but now that I've got it, I'm pretty happy reading on Comixology. This story centers on racism, which is a complicated topic, and I thought that this novel (aimed at the YA crowd) handled all of the complicated aspects well. I'm adding it to our high school reading list, and I'd recommend it to adults as well. I found that when Superman says, "We are bound together by the future. We all share the same tomorrow. -That he could be speaking to all of us in 2020.

I enjoyed this book. There is plenty of suspense to hold your interest. The artwork is very good and suitable to an American classic The story is mostly set in 1946, with flashbacks to Superman’s origins. His parents make several appearances through the power of memory projection. The plot centers around the Lee family that moved from Chinatown to Metropolis. They meet both friendship and racism. There is exciting action and the violence is not overdone. Long time fans of Superman will love the nostalgia, even though the presentation is modern. You’ll find some history of the Chinese-American experience in the appendix. This is printed in Canada. Recommended.

I thoroughly enjoyed this DC Ink title from start to finish. I honestly had a hard time putting it down. This story has a really nuanced take on hate groups and others’ susceptibilities to them (as well as the mindset in the hate groups) while also being light and fun. It strikes the perfect balance of 1940s atmosphere and even manners of speaking with a modern day lens and sentimentality to it. I especially appreciated the essay at the end that interweaves US History, Superman’s history, and the author’s personal story. It was a great touch. I definitely recommend this title.

Like many of us, I grew up on Superman. He was the paragon of virtue that all of us were to aspire. My first introduction was the old serial cartoons made in the 1940s. My dad bought me a VHS copy in the early 90s at a garage sale. I watched it repeatedly because it was simple: Superman is good and right and true; he overcomes the bad guys with his might. Rinse and repeat every nine minutes. Mechanical monsters, evil super-geniuses, arctic giants, and volcanos– these were his enemies as far as I was concerned. It never occurred to me that Superman needed to fight hate and racism, but he did. In 1946, “The Adventures of Superman,” a popular radio show that aired from 1940 to 1951, took on the Klan. During the years of World War II, the show often had Superman battle and overcome the Nazis. It was easy to write with great payoff because America wanted to beat the Axis. However, with the Allies winning and the Nazis defeated, it didn’t make sense for Superman to continue fighting them. The producers of the show were looking for a new villain, and Klan activity was on the rise in the northern United States. According to who you talk to, it was several people’s idea to have the show go after the Klan, but what’s important is that it happened and they had the courage and support to do it. “Clan of the Fiery Cross” was born as a stand-in for the Klu Klux Klan for legal purposes. We need to remember that the KKK, then as it is today, is litigious and organized with dues, budgets, and marketing campaigns. Superman took on the “Clan” and punched racism in the face. While thinly veiled, it worked, and ratings skyrocketed while Klan leaders denounced the show. Fast-forward to 2019: “Superman Smashes the Klan,” written by Gene Luen Yang with art by Gurihiru, is released as a three-part serial and is loosely based on the aforementioned radio show. Set in 1946, a Chinese-American family moves to the suburbs of Metropolis and out of Chinatown. The Lees are not welcome by all, and some are so disturbed by them moving in that a flaming cross appears on their front lawn. The focus of the story is on the two Lee children, Tommy and Roberta. Tommy is a gifted athlete who quickly usurps the mantle of starting pitcher on the community center baseball team. The former starting pitcher’s uncle is the “Grand Scorpion” of Metropolis’ local Klan chapter. Yang shows an interesting dichotomy with the uncle because when his nephew talks about being replaced, he essentially tells him to take it in stride and do better next time. That is until he hears the name “Lee.” His entire mood changes, and he practically goes for his robes right there. I’m pointing to this moment because we often hear, “well, he’s always been nice to me.” It’s a familiar character defense that comes up regularly when somebody accuses another of racism, sexism, or xenophobia. Yang lifts the veil of this defense as well as sheds light on the duality of racism. This theme is done deftly and sometimes overtly throughout the story. You can forgive the use of overt themes in place of subtly once you understand the history of this story and from what it was adapted. The art is done in a playful way to showcase how different this is from the modern tellings of Superman of this current decade. It also achieves that shiny veneer and idyllic view of the past that so many of us have but also reveals how Camelot was a lie for people who looked different than Superman or me. Setting the story in Gotham, the reader wouldn’t feel like it was that much of a stretch to see police corruption, systemic racism, casual xenophobia, etc. But Metropolis is the shining city upon a hill (even with death rays). Certain characters even voice their disbelief in the kind of activities that take place, including our favorite veteran paperman Perry White. While Superman swooping in to save the Lee family from drowning, bombs and Klan activity is the main plot; the b-plot is Supes dealing with his own identity and the development of his powers. Superman can only leap, and his eyes only see. The comic goes out of its way to remind us of the early history of his character and limited abilities. These two stories are fantastic on their own, but at times they feel clumsy when smashed together. Going back and forth, you keep wondering whether this is a story about an immigrant family struggling with the Klan with the help of Superman or a Superman story struggling with his parentage while punching the Klan. The connections between the two stories of self-identity and immigration are tenuous at best, that is until the end. Yang does stick the landing when Superman accepts he’s an alien and an immigrant and proudly reveals it to the world. Superman’s revelation mirrors Roberta Lee’s journey and the acceptance of her issues as well as her birth name. Overall, this is an entertaining read with a pertinent message and, sadly, still a timely one, but it can either give you a glimpse of your past or small window into one you’ve never experienced. If you do read it, I recommend you make sure to read the epilogue written by Yang. It gives a brief history of the plight of Chinese-Americans, Klan activity, and his own experiences growing up. It is just as interesting as the Superman story the proceeds it and, in my opinion, should have been the prologue. It gives much more depth and understanding to the reader. Tristan Riddell Co-Founder and Publisher TheNerdParty.com

Inspired by a classic Superman radio show from the 1940s, this graphic novel goes deeper, using Superman and some new characters to examine issues of immigration (especially for 2nd generation immigrants), prejudice, self-acceptance, and belonging. Superman has always had immigration themes, but it's interesting to see that related to the Chinese American experience. If you're looking for a super-subtle story, this ain't it. This comic embraces its pulp roots; the head villains are mostly one-dimensional. But by incorporating the meditation about immigration with the pulpiness, the comic feels fresh. The cartooning is slick and well done, with story-appropriate 1940s styling. I'm glad I read this book.

Thank you to Netgalley for the opportunity to read and review this graphic novel. This book harkens back to the simpler comics of yesteryear. The graphics are not annoyingly complicated or bizarre that you tend to find in current graphic novels. The story is likewise simple but effectively told. The story is an interesting take on Superman's early years when he has recently gone out on his own and is still 'finding' himself. One would not realize that he had to learn that it was OK to fly while being a good deed doer.

Gene Luen Yang's award-winning American Born Chinese was amazing, and he made another phenomenal masterpiece with this graphic novel! Imagining Superman in the 50's (non-flying, as he was then) the story parallels his unsettling memories of his identity as an alien and others' fear of and misunderstanding of him (before he became a kind of model-minority) with the Lee family's struggle to both assimilate and retain their culture in a majority-white town steeped in systemic racism. Incredible, powerful, and fun book.

The perfect antidote for the gloom and dourness of the recent movies, this is Superman as an inspirational figure and protector. Set early in Superman’s career - he’s still leaping tall buildings, not flying - he must defend Metropolis and a Chinese family from the Klan. There’s a great subtext about immigrants denying their true selves in order to “fit in,” as Earth’s most prominent alien discovers how he’s limiting himself. Absolutely loved this book, and I hope to see more of the Lee children in the future.

My 10-year-old son devoured this graphic novel and came to me with tons of thoughtful questions. Hooray! That is the power of a good book! With a focus on the dangers of the KKK towards Asian Americans, this book works well to demonstrate the hatred of the klan and why they are evil villains. For my son, it was a great way to discuss racism in America through the lens of a superhero. He learned more from this graphic novel than he did when he studied the topic in school. Plus, the illustrations are superb. BRAVO!

I wish I were familiar with the radio serial that this is inspired by, because after reading this, I'm interested in that now! I appreciate the depth and meaning of the story being told (and it's well written!). My daughter loves graphic novels and this one is great for her- it's captivating and not a super complicated read- but also not boring. An ideal graphic novel. I also appreciate the way Superman is portrayed. My daughter and I both enjoy this one! Note that the suggested age listed on the product page is 12 and up. I think some younger kids might do well with but that's always best left to the parent's judgement.

This Superman graphic novel is best suited for an audience a year or two below YA level. Story is decent and the anti racism messaging is on point and pacing is very good and moves along at a nice clip. Artwork is the standout feature here with clear and expressive illustration from Japanese manga duo Gurihiru who manages to pull off an expressive art style that comfortably sits between the stylistics of manga and Western superhero comic art.

This is a really great graphic novel, perfect for kids and adults alike. Love the emphasis on compassion, acceptance, and good overcoming evil in society. Superman's existential angst was a great allegory for the feeling of not belonging that people sometimes have living in the U.S. when they are different, and I loved how invested this made him in fighting bigotry. Also, the Lee family was awesome-- Tommy and Roberta were such great characters.

If anyone conplains that the subject matter is unfit for kids, tell them to look at what's going on in the world. This book came out at just the right time because it's all about the importance of listening to and learning from people of color. The writing manages to be harrowing without being graphic. Overall, an important superhero book that is less about Superman and more about what makes a hero.

I may be biased because I love Golden Age Superman and also the 16 episode radio show "Clan of the Fiery Cross" but this is one of the greatest Superman stories of all time. I find this story to be a better, more improved version of the radio show. Please DC, more Superman comics like this, helping the little guy. He is the champion of the oppressed.

My 18 year old son unofficially collects comic books (well, he is pretty meticulous -- he has them on in plastic sleeves with the cardboard in them). He has probably 500 comics. He is really into comics. And he loved this book. He loved the story. He loved the artwork. It was really good. For comic book lovers this is the perfect gift.

Love me some old school Superman. In this one we get to see super man at the height of the Klan. Fighting back with the best of them. I loved the drawing. It felt classic but not too old school. The wording was well for the time period. Overall a good long comic to add to any Superman loving fan.

A seriously well done script and very good graphics combine in a story that, while it should be historic (takes place in 1946) is, sadly, all too relevant to today While I hesitate to call it "must read", "really ought to read" is right on the mark

This is a cute story with adventurous drawings. a family moves from China Town to Metropolis and encounters discrimination from Neo-Nazis who are sheet covered members of the Klu Klux Klan. One new member dislikes what he sees. Superman becomes involved, has problems, but ultimately is successful.

I really enjoyed this graphic novel and I will see about getting a copy for the student library. The illustrations really worked well to help tell the story. Superman fighting the white supremacy and hate is just what we need right now.

Very timely story. The art is ok but not great.

Easily one of my favorite books this year. The art and writing are both fantastic, and it is a very important story for kids to read in these times. I'm going to recommend this to everyone.

Classic Superman retelling with moral lessons. Really enjoyed this! Would love to see the author do more Superman books and other superheroes as well!

Gene Yang knows how to write simply, powerfully, and with meaning. Superman is a character from people and all ages, and Gene proves that with this story. I want more.

An excellent adaptation of the Superman radio serial that cuts to the core of Superman's roots juxtaposed with a Chinese family settling into life in Metropolis. The only detractor (even though it helps deepen supporting characters) is the smattering of racist comments from white characters.