Pit Bull: The Battle over an American Icon

I bought this book because I am a pit rescue owner. I had never owned a dog as a child and went to the shelter to volunteer, I left in tears because of the sad energy and hopelessness..I decided to try again and the same thing happened although I left with my first dog who happened to be a APBT...I know not the best first time dog to rescue..he was going to be euthinized and he looked at me and I looked at him and I never looked back..he was my dog soulmate..now my husband didn't necessarily agree he had been raised with the pitbull stereotype and it took only one incident to seal the deal. My son was born with some medical issues, the first week we had our dog (Apollo) my son had him in his room and had gotten sick and was in the restroom with a fever and had passed out..it was the middle of the night..Apollo started barking to get our attention and led us to our son..after that it was it for us, 4 years later he is literally my second child and we've rescued another APBT (his sister) since then. I will only rescue and I am so touched by the writing of this author not only is she well read she has a passion for this breed I can appreciate and admire...this book is excellent!!!

*THIS* is how a non-fiction book is supposed to be written. It is extremely clear when reading the book the amount of research that went into it. Not just searching google and looking for user comments or reading news articles, but actual legitimate research, interviews and more research. This book not only delves into the history of the breed, the reputation of the breed, but looks at modern, peer reviewed, scientific research papers that have been performed to show the major discrepancies between reality and "hysteria". She's done a wonderful job of delving into the psyche of humans in the modern world and why we are so prone to buy into hysteria, while discounting all facts that show us the error of our ways. I agree with other reviewers about the context of this book being more about people than dogs. It uses the topic of "Pit Bulls", which isn't even a specific dog breed, to explore people and try to make sense of some of our more senseless ways. I just finished this book and couldn't be more pleased. I have to say, this is one of the best non-fiction books I have read. As an aside, scary but also eye-roll worthy, I got up this morning and someone had sent me a good write-up regarding the book since they knew I was reading it. It's about the author and the craziness she has had thrown her way since writing the book: You can find it by googling "How Writing About Pit Bulls Led to Death Threats, Online and IRL". It's on lithub. I've noticed several other articles throughout the last few weeks speaking about the crazy experiences book stores and this author have had from the same small group of people. It would be ridiculous and laugh worthy, if it wasn't reality. Luckily, it's a very small group of people involved but the reason I feel this is relevant enough to add to my review is because it's basically an extension of what Ms. Dickey explains in her book. It's not the dogs that are the problem. It is now and has always been the people that are the problem. Regardless of what side of the fence they are on, whether they are irresponsible owners, dog fighters using the dogs to profit, or people who consider themselves crusaders who spend their life attacking innocent pet owners over their choice of pet, all of the issues related to dogs of any breed can always be traced back to people. I also agree with the above mentioned article that Mrs. Dickey would not be getting as much vitriol from this group if she were a man, and she definitely wouldn't be getting daily attacks from these people regarding her looks (She's quite pretty but people get petty when it comes to hysteria). Which is yet another interesting aspect of our modern day culture. That's a whole different topic (but not really since it's based on the same fears) that could have a similar book written about it. Maybe Mrs. Dickey can explore that topic in the future.

Mind. Blown. I've been struggling with how to begin my review about the latest book I read to add to my animal advocate education – Bronwen Dickey's “Pit Bull: The Battle Over an American Icon” - and ultimately decided I needed to start with what the book did to me and for me. It blew my mind and I mean that in a good way. I have so many adjectives inside my head to describe the book that it's hard to know just where to start. Beautiful, amazing, encyclopedic, scientific, endearing, frustrating, enlightening, empowering. This book is hands down the most comprehensive coverage of the topic of pit bull type dogs in our society which I have read in the last decade. I cannot implore you strongly enough: if you read one book this year that relates to companion animals in our society, please make it this one. I have already purchased additional copies to share with my local shelter director, a city councilman and some others I think may benefit from the information. I came to the book somewhat indirectly and still shake my head that I was unaware of it until it had been in print for a while. I'm not new to many of the topics covered in the book, having done a lot of research in the past related to pit bull type dogs. The best treatise on the subject of pit bull type dogs up until recently was written by Karen Delise who, to this day, is still considered the foremost authority on Dog Bite Related Fatalities (DBRFs). I learned about Bronwen's book after banging my head against a wall related to some people who promote a website which is used either to justify disparate treatment of the dogs or as part of an effort to render pit bull type dogs extinct. It is the scope of Bronwen's book which blew my mind and which I am still processing even weeks after having finished reading it. It contains so much information that there is no way I can do it justice with a short review. The book is not just about dogs and how we have breed dogs to look like hundreds of different species (often to their detriment) and how we judge dogs by what we see and what we fear. It is also about our society and how we judge dogs based on who owns them and what purposes they serve (or we think they serve) for those people. This book is as much an examination of how we view each other, be it right or wrong, as how we view the dogs with whom we share our lives. Learn about our history with dogs, pit bull type dogs in general, the role of the media related to pit bull type dogs, our fears related to dogs, Breed Specific Legislation, dog breeds, DNA testing, dogs in animal shelters, dog bites and dog bite related fatalities, the National Canine Research Council, the Animal Farm Foundation and about those who claim to be experts about pit bull type dogs but who are not. Those topics are all covered in this wonderful book, and then some.

I rarely post a review, but in this case I feel the need given how impressive I found this book. For anyone who is wondering if this book is just about describing the Pit Bull "breed", for anyone who is wondering if your limited interest about Pit Bulls justifies the effort to read of a book with more than 340 pages, my feedback is clear: this is not a "simple" book about a breed, it is a book about sociology, it is a book about understanding how the press misleads perceptions, about how dogs in general and Pit Bulls in particular, intersect with the human society,about racism, about how the breeds we call "pit bulls"have been chased unfairly and portrayed like an evil breed when they are wonderful dogs. Even if you do not like put bulls, if you are interested in sociology you will love to read this book. Extremely well researched and a real pleasure to read.

This is a comprehensive, unbiased book on everything related to Pit Bull dogs in the U.S. starting with the earliest history of the dogs. Included are dog bite statistics, History of the data available down through the years, analysis of the papers written by doctors and plastic surgeons, including Pinkney and Kennedy, and current dog bite statistics with references and supporting documentation. Dickey investigates and interviews academics, researchers, dog behaviorists, and dog bite statistic experts, vocal public figures who have been advocates for Pit Bulls, as well as those who say they're a danger to society. Only an accomplished writer can pack all this information and detail into one book and still make it an enjoyable read.

I just finished reading the new book 'Pit Bull The Battle over an American Icon'. The author Bronwen Dickey did exhaustive research for this book. It should be required reading for anyone that owns a pit bull and actually for anyone that owns any type of dog. You will learn much about World and American history. How much of what the media reported was in error and why human deaths by other types of dogs are not reported. The ban and hysteria surrounding pit bulls is SO much more than the dog known as a pit bull. Currently we have 5 dogs, 1 a German Shepherd mix, 1 a lab mix and 3 that are pit bull mixes. I am also a certified dog trainer. I have to admit when we got our 1st pit bull, a 5 year old neutered male from a rescue, even though I knew better, the media had still done a number on my psyche. But my new adopted boy, Beaux, proved the media was wrong. What Beaux is, is the most loyal dog I have ever had, he has a great sense of humor and I am sure would protect me if needed. From a dog trainer perspective and I have had many pit bulls as clients, they are a very smart and love to learn especially when using clicker training. I just wish people would realize they are most of all, just dogs.

Finally a source of the complete history of pit bulls. The times that they were appreciated for the dogs they were . And then their fall from grace as much for cultural issues as breed issues. Their history as war dogs. The environment of today where a lot of the places pits live is in the dangerous part of a neighborhood. The actual comparison of biting and death by pits as compared to other dogs. Only 35 deaths a year are attributable to dogs. And of those only a small number are pit bulls. Having worked in a local pet rescue, I am quite familiar with these dogs and they can be wonderful pets. Often aggression can be because male dogs are not neutered or raised in a home where they are not socialized. Enjoy the read and use the information when you hear someone undermining all pits.

Despite the many bad comments, I can't imagine those people read this book, or if they did, they went in with a hateful narrow mind. This book is well written and presents facts. Bully breeds all over the world face discrimination, hatred, abuse and death, all because people refuse to actually learn the truth, basic canine communication, and understand that dogs are individuals; and prefer gross discrimination and knee jerk reactions that kill innocent dogs and destroy families. (Not to me.nation breed bans have been proven time and time again not to work). Not every person deserves a dog, let alone a powerful bully breed, but every dog, including bully breeds, do deserve a good home. If you are curious about bully breeds, this is a great place to start. If you are looking for a book that support your hate towards them and shows them as monsters, this isn't it.

I am a dog lover and willing to give other dog lovers a lot of latitude. I am aware of the effort to "rebrand" this particular group of dogs because of the bad press they have gotten in the past. Despite my "progressive thinking" and my liberal attitude, i am ashamed to admit that I have said and thought many of the ignorant ideas mentioned in this book. Well, not anymore. I am sure I will have beliefs based on ignorance but it won't be about pit bulls. I only wish that some of the people cited in the book would admit they are wrong and get on with their lives, but there are a couple examples that fit the adage about teaching a pig to sing. Either they don't read the scientific studies or they are just too proud to admit that they don't know as much as they think they do. Bronwen Dickey is very gentle with some of her case studies who I would consider overweening know-it-alls. If you love dogs and would like the facts served up with heartwarming and colorful anecdotes, you need to read "Pit Bull"

I purchased this book some months ago from Amazon and have finally found time to read it. I tend not to enjoy "research" type texts very much but this was a surprising exception. I've never owned a Pit Bull but was drawn to the recent controversy over BSL recently and thought this was a good supplement to my education on the issue. The "real-life" stories are a very functional counterpart to the research and data components and keep you moving through the pages. There are moments of pure sadness in the book as well as times of elation. The book certainly points out the shortcomings of human beings and the forgiveness and patience of the species we refer to as "Dog". Highly recommended.

I bought this book because I am a pit rescue owner. I had never owned a dog as a child and went to the shelter to volunteer, I left in tears because of the sad energy and hopelessness..I decided to try again and the same thing happened although I left with my first dog who happened to be a APBT...I know not the best first time dog to rescue..he was going to be euthinized and he looked at me and I looked at him and I never looked back..he was my dog soulmate..now my husband didn't necessarily agree he had been raised with the pitbull stereotype and it took only one incident to seal the deal. My son was born with some medical issues, the first week we had our dog (Apollo) my son had him in his room and had gotten sick and was in the restroom with a fever and had passed out..it was the middle of the night..Apollo started barking to get our attention and led us to our son..after that it was it for us, 4 years later he is literally my second child and we've rescued another APBT (his sister) since then. I will only rescue and I am so touched by the writing of this author not only is she well read she has a passion for this breed I can appreciate and admire...this book is excellent!!!

*THIS* is how a non-fiction book is supposed to be written. It is extremely clear when reading the book the amount of research that went into it. Not just searching google and looking for user comments or reading news articles, but actual legitimate research, interviews and more research. This book not only delves into the history of the breed, the reputation of the breed, but looks at modern, peer reviewed, scientific research papers that have been performed to show the major discrepancies between reality and "hysteria". She's done a wonderful job of delving into the psyche of humans in the modern world and why we are so prone to buy into hysteria, while discounting all facts that show us the error of our ways. I agree with other reviewers about the context of this book being more about people than dogs. It uses the topic of "Pit Bulls", which isn't even a specific dog breed, to explore people and try to make sense of some of our more senseless ways. I just finished this book and couldn't be more pleased. I have to say, this is one of the best non-fiction books I have read. As an aside, scary but also eye-roll worthy, I got up this morning and someone had sent me a good write-up regarding the book since they knew I was reading it. It's about the author and the craziness she has had thrown her way since writing the book: You can find it by googling "How Writing About Pit Bulls Led to Death Threats, Online and IRL". It's on lithub. I've noticed several other articles throughout the last few weeks speaking about the crazy experiences book stores and this author have had from the same small group of people. It would be ridiculous and laugh worthy, if it wasn't reality. Luckily, it's a very small group of people involved but the reason I feel this is relevant enough to add to my review is because it's basically an extension of what Ms. Dickey explains in her book. It's not the dogs that are the problem. It is now and has always been the people that are the problem. Regardless of what side of the fence they are on, whether they are irresponsible owners, dog fighters using the dogs to profit, or people who consider themselves crusaders who spend their life attacking innocent pet owners over their choice of pet, all of the issues related to dogs of any breed can always be traced back to people. I also agree with the above mentioned article that Mrs. Dickey would not be getting as much vitriol from this group if she were a man, and she definitely wouldn't be getting daily attacks from these people regarding her looks (She's quite pretty but people get petty when it comes to hysteria). Which is yet another interesting aspect of our modern day culture. That's a whole different topic (but not really since it's based on the same fears) that could have a similar book written about it. Maybe Mrs. Dickey can explore that topic in the future.

Mind. Blown. I've been struggling with how to begin my review about the latest book I read to add to my animal advocate education – Bronwen Dickey's “Pit Bull: The Battle Over an American Icon” - and ultimately decided I needed to start with what the book did to me and for me. It blew my mind and I mean that in a good way. I have so many adjectives inside my head to describe the book that it's hard to know just where to start. Beautiful, amazing, encyclopedic, scientific, endearing, frustrating, enlightening, empowering. This book is hands down the most comprehensive coverage of the topic of pit bull type dogs in our society which I have read in the last decade. I cannot implore you strongly enough: if you read one book this year that relates to companion animals in our society, please make it this one. I have already purchased additional copies to share with my local shelter director, a city councilman and some others I think may benefit from the information. I came to the book somewhat indirectly and still shake my head that I was unaware of it until it had been in print for a while. I'm not new to many of the topics covered in the book, having done a lot of research in the past related to pit bull type dogs. The best treatise on the subject of pit bull type dogs up until recently was written by Karen Delise who, to this day, is still considered the foremost authority on Dog Bite Related Fatalities (DBRFs). I learned about Bronwen's book after banging my head against a wall related to some people who promote a website which is used either to justify disparate treatment of the dogs or as part of an effort to render pit bull type dogs extinct. It is the scope of Bronwen's book which blew my mind and which I am still processing even weeks after having finished reading it. It contains so much information that there is no way I can do it justice with a short review. The book is not just about dogs and how we have breed dogs to look like hundreds of different species (often to their detriment) and how we judge dogs by what we see and what we fear. It is also about our society and how we judge dogs based on who owns them and what purposes they serve (or we think they serve) for those people. This book is as much an examination of how we view each other, be it right or wrong, as how we view the dogs with whom we share our lives. Learn about our history with dogs, pit bull type dogs in general, the role of the media related to pit bull type dogs, our fears related to dogs, Breed Specific Legislation, dog breeds, DNA testing, dogs in animal shelters, dog bites and dog bite related fatalities, the National Canine Research Council, the Animal Farm Foundation and about those who claim to be experts about pit bull type dogs but who are not. Those topics are all covered in this wonderful book, and then some.

I rarely post a review, but in this case I feel the need given how impressive I found this book. For anyone who is wondering if this book is just about describing the Pit Bull "breed", for anyone who is wondering if your limited interest about Pit Bulls justifies the effort to read of a book with more than 340 pages, my feedback is clear: this is not a "simple" book about a breed, it is a book about sociology, it is a book about understanding how the press misleads perceptions, about how dogs in general and Pit Bulls in particular, intersect with the human society,about racism, about how the breeds we call "pit bulls"have been chased unfairly and portrayed like an evil breed when they are wonderful dogs. Even if you do not like put bulls, if you are interested in sociology you will love to read this book. Extremely well researched and a real pleasure to read.

This is a comprehensive, unbiased book on everything related to Pit Bull dogs in the U.S. starting with the earliest history of the dogs. Included are dog bite statistics, History of the data available down through the years, analysis of the papers written by doctors and plastic surgeons, including Pinkney and Kennedy, and current dog bite statistics with references and supporting documentation. Dickey investigates and interviews academics, researchers, dog behaviorists, and dog bite statistic experts, vocal public figures who have been advocates for Pit Bulls, as well as those who say they're a danger to society. Only an accomplished writer can pack all this information and detail into one book and still make it an enjoyable read.

I just finished reading the new book 'Pit Bull The Battle over an American Icon'. The author Bronwen Dickey did exhaustive research for this book. It should be required reading for anyone that owns a pit bull and actually for anyone that owns any type of dog. You will learn much about World and American history. How much of what the media reported was in error and why human deaths by other types of dogs are not reported. The ban and hysteria surrounding pit bulls is SO much more than the dog known as a pit bull. Currently we have 5 dogs, 1 a German Shepherd mix, 1 a lab mix and 3 that are pit bull mixes. I am also a certified dog trainer. I have to admit when we got our 1st pit bull, a 5 year old neutered male from a rescue, even though I knew better, the media had still done a number on my psyche. But my new adopted boy, Beaux, proved the media was wrong. What Beaux is, is the most loyal dog I have ever had, he has a great sense of humor and I am sure would protect me if needed. From a dog trainer perspective and I have had many pit bulls as clients, they are a very smart and love to learn especially when using clicker training. I just wish people would realize they are most of all, just dogs.

Finally a source of the complete history of pit bulls. The times that they were appreciated for the dogs they were . And then their fall from grace as much for cultural issues as breed issues. Their history as war dogs. The environment of today where a lot of the places pits live is in the dangerous part of a neighborhood. The actual comparison of biting and death by pits as compared to other dogs. Only 35 deaths a year are attributable to dogs. And of those only a small number are pit bulls. Having worked in a local pet rescue, I am quite familiar with these dogs and they can be wonderful pets. Often aggression can be because male dogs are not neutered or raised in a home where they are not socialized. Enjoy the read and use the information when you hear someone undermining all pits.

Despite the many bad comments, I can't imagine those people read this book, or if they did, they went in with a hateful narrow mind. This book is well written and presents facts. Bully breeds all over the world face discrimination, hatred, abuse and death, all because people refuse to actually learn the truth, basic canine communication, and understand that dogs are individuals; and prefer gross discrimination and knee jerk reactions that kill innocent dogs and destroy families. (Not to me.nation breed bans have been proven time and time again not to work). Not every person deserves a dog, let alone a powerful bully breed, but every dog, including bully breeds, do deserve a good home. If you are curious about bully breeds, this is a great place to start. If you are looking for a book that support your hate towards them and shows them as monsters, this isn't it.

I am a dog lover and willing to give other dog lovers a lot of latitude. I am aware of the effort to "rebrand" this particular group of dogs because of the bad press they have gotten in the past. Despite my "progressive thinking" and my liberal attitude, i am ashamed to admit that I have said and thought many of the ignorant ideas mentioned in this book. Well, not anymore. I am sure I will have beliefs based on ignorance but it won't be about pit bulls. I only wish that some of the people cited in the book would admit they are wrong and get on with their lives, but there are a couple examples that fit the adage about teaching a pig to sing. Either they don't read the scientific studies or they are just too proud to admit that they don't know as much as they think they do. Bronwen Dickey is very gentle with some of her case studies who I would consider overweening know-it-alls. If you love dogs and would like the facts served up with heartwarming and colorful anecdotes, you need to read "Pit Bull"

I purchased this book some months ago from Amazon and have finally found time to read it. I tend not to enjoy "research" type texts very much but this was a surprising exception. I've never owned a Pit Bull but was drawn to the recent controversy over BSL recently and thought this was a good supplement to my education on the issue. The "real-life" stories are a very functional counterpart to the research and data components and keep you moving through the pages. There are moments of pure sadness in the book as well as times of elation. The book certainly points out the shortcomings of human beings and the forgiveness and patience of the species we refer to as "Dog". Highly recommended.

I originally picked up this book at the library for my sister to read. Unfortunately, she had no interest in reading the book and I intended to return it to the library. Then out of curiosity I picked it up and started to read. Immediately, I was hooked. The book is very interesting from the first page to the last. I learned all about the history of this breed and what a beloved part of Americana they once were. I also learned how they, often unfairly, earned a bad rap. I found the book fair and very well researched and documented, (for those of us who like to further read up on a subject). While I am still not a fan of the breed, preferring Beagles instead, I now have a different opinion and no longer view them as mindless killing machines so often portrayed by many. I enjoyed the book so much that I purchased it as a gift through Amazon to give to a friend. I'm sure she'll enjoy reading it too.

I'm pretty sure I've reviewed this already, but here goes - This is a good, entertaining book which deals with the history of the several types of dog which are currently referred to as "pit bulls". It goes into some of the variations in dog temperament (of dogs generally), and it refutes most of the erroneous claims about pit bull behavior. While it's true that the author is clearly an admirer of pit bulls, this book should be an enjoyable, informative read for anyone who thinks about this category of dogs. It's a warning to all of us, that we should not uncritically accept urban myths about any breed of dog.

Fantastic book... helps you appreciate all that is wonderful with pit bulls, and helps you understand the false stories that are told about these truly loving dogs. Thank you Ms. Dickey for this book! Beyond reading and learning and understanding, our daughter also used it as a great reference for a speech about BSLs / Breed Specific Laws, laws about specific animal breeds. This helped her educate others, too.

This book is a MUST HAVE for anyone wanting to understand more than just the history of pit bulls, and how we ended up demonizing them. It is extremely well documented and written. It explains dog genetics and how breeds work, it detailed the history of pit bulls and where the dogs came from. More importantly, it is a detailed and extremely intelligent exploration of the historical mechanisms by which pit bulls became the symbols of tensions between communities, races and socioeconomic classes. Even if you are not interested in pit bulls per se, I highly recommend this book. It's a fascinating look on our society, the power of the media and the animal welfare community. MUST HAVE.

Pitbull: The Battle over an American Icon is a book all pitbull owners should read. It's also a fantastic book for anyone with the fear of pit bulls and wonders why so many people defend them. The media has started a phobia of this breed. Scientific evidence backs up the people defending this breed and this book breaks down any questions pitbull lovers or people who has a fear of them might have. This was the best book I ever read on facts and it explained why there's such a fear of the breed. I am a person who likes facts, not opinions. I read this book because, common sense told me there couldn't be such a monstrous dog. We would all be dead already if the media and social media was right about these dogs. Also, so many defend this breed. This book cleared up what I already knew. Pit bulls are just ordinary dogs and it's their turn to be demonized. It made me wonder which breed was next and how the people who have so much hatred would feel if their dog was targeted next. Fantastic book!!

I volunteer at an Oakland animal shelter that is chock full of pit bull type dogs, and this book truly is a gift. I spend a lot of time talking to people about pit bulls, and this book was so helpful in really learning the science and facts behind all of the negative hype. I'm ordering a bunch of additional copies of the book to put in the shelter library so other volunteers can read it. Thank you Bronwen for such a exhaustive research, in such an accessible book.

I worried that this very researched book might be too academic and be a chore to read, but I couldn't put it down. I stayed up night after night reading it. I found it enthralling. As a shelter volunteer I learned so much that can help me with my work. But as a dog lover in general I learned so much that deepens my appreciation for dogs and our relationships with them over centuries. This book is so full of interesting information about dogs in general, and specifically when it comes to pit bulls, what a wonderful and exhaustive dive into who they are and who we are around them. I give this book my highest recommendation!

This was a well-written, highly informative and emotional read. It’s clear the author invested a great deal of time interviewing subjects with differing opinions on the pit breeds, researching animal behavior and generally navigating all the controversy surrounding pit bulls to give the reader a balanced take on how they became such polarizing figures in American culture. From the various pit breeds’ origins, to their prominent place in American society to their subsequent fall from grace, the author digs into events that created and has maintained the image of pits as America’s most demonized animal: -distortion of “facts/evidence” by scientists, particularly those lacking animal behavioral expertise, -rampant stereotyping & fear mongering, -overgeneralization of anecdotes -shoddy research, -media sensationalism, -faulty breed regulation My big takeaway was that pits are inherently happy, people-pleasing creatures and the only place where blame and, more importantly, concern regarding these breeds should be placed is in the darker elements of human nature as that has shaped (read: devastated) the lives and reputations of millions of dogs.

Whether you are a pitbull advocate or strictly against the breed, you need to read this book. Dickey presents TONS of evidence from primary sources, newspaper articles, and scientific studies. Her research is not biased, and she presents both sides of the "story." The history is in-depth and broad, and she leaves out nothing, however gruesome it may be. Dickey presents arguments from both sides of the spectrum, but mostly focuses on the media hype that created a world of lies. Everyone in America needs to read this book. If you are a pitbull lover, it will help you understand the breed and love them even more. If you hate the breed, take the time to educate yourself and be aware of your own feelings and the things you are spreading. If you're afraid to read and educate yourself based on facts, then you probably shouldn't be so certain about your opinion.

I give 5 stars to this book. It’s not only about pit bull but also about us the humans, how we look at other species with all our strengths and weaknesses inherent in us and in our vision. Ms Bronwen Dickey, we are looking forward to read your next book.

Bronwen Dickey's book was one of the best books I've read in a very long time....one of those books that I couldn't put down.. I ended up reading it cover to cover and then immediately started to read it again because there was so much in the writing. Whether or not you have an interest in pit bulls, rescue or animal welfare, the areas of the book which delve into the human aspect are so worth the read. Meticulously researched, beautiful, stunning and poignant.

Bronwen Dickey has done an excellent job compiling actual facts along with historical data, rumor and legend giving us the most comprehensive look at a true American Icon. I do not agree with all of her statements in the book regarding some of the rumors and legends, but the facts are undeniable, unless you've never taken a science or history class...or are just completely insane. I do agree with one of her statements 100%..."Pit bulls are just...dogs", which can be applied to all breeds. Anyone who disagrees with that after reviewing the scientific facts she presents, should probably see a psychologist, because they have deeper issues they need to deal with than their fear of other people and their dogs.

Very well researched. Wouldn’t recommend to someone who completely new to the whole good/bad pit bull debate. But for those who have already done some research on pit bulls it offers a new and refreshing view point. I don’t agree however with her on the point that breed bans are based on a desire to get at a certain race. Had some good points . Was over all a good read.

A great and informative read. It sheds light on not only the prejudice that put bills face but other breeds. This book doesn't just pertain to pit bulls but all dogs and as dog owners is important that we don't forget.

This book is well thought out and is a worthwhile read for all. It is well researched and thought provoking. It deftly puts into context the issues present in today's society and dispels with the notion of binary world of good vs. evil with the answer being as simple as the eradication of the "pit bull." It touches on much larger societal issues such as the loss of reason, fear mongering, misguided public policy and the disparate impact the irrational attack on the "pit bull" has on the poorer populations. It simply is a must read for all.

As someone who knew very little about pit bulls before reading, this book was an amazing learning experience, eye opener, tear-jerker, and journey. I’d recommend it to anyone—-whether an experienced dog owner or just a ‘newbie’ curious about dog breeds and dog care.

I heard the author on a talk radio show and decided to get this book and give it a read. This book gives great and educational information on the origin and past of the Pitbull, how the breed started as an American icon, and how it became an American nightmare. You can tell that the author spent many hours researching and talking to experts on the breed and some of those who have been negatively affected by the breed. I recommend this book to not only fans of the Pitbull but to anyone who would like to gain a better understanding of, in my opinion, truly, this misunderstood and at times scapegoated breed.

I will update this review as soon as I am done with the book but as of now I am only halfway through but I am compelled to write a review due to the fantastic scientific writing and documentation included by the author. Please note that I am a verified purchaser of the book unlike the one star reviews by pitbull haters. My master's thesis (last year) was on the fallacy of breed-specific legislation and I always said I should compile the data and write a pro-pitbull book; the author beat me to the punch and included all of the data I used along with so much more that I had never encountered. This is not fluff nor "PR," this is the actual science behind the fact that the dogs are inherently good and are the victims of bad owners most of the times that they "go bad." This is not the forum to debate the topic but please read this book if you are able and then bring one of these amazing dogs in to your life. I work in animal welfare and it breaks my heart to see such an amazing breed be looked over or demonized time and time again due to stupid people abusing/neglecting them, fighting them, or demonizing them when dog attacks have things in common 93% of the time: (no, not breed) the dogs are unaltered. This is according to the CDC, people, not the author. A great book so far and I will update shortly.

Love this book... so sad that humans have given Pit Bulls such a horrible rap. These are the most wonderful, soft, loving, tender spirits...that want nothing more than to please their humans. Even after they've been abused beyond the human imagination, they will still want to love a human, after they are rescued... it always blows me away, to witness their awesome loving spirit.

It's a carefully documented essay on the history of irrational fears down through history and how our fears of each other are reflected in our persecution of pets.

This is a very important book. It goes well beyond being a thorough analysis about pit bull dogs. It's about how me often fail to make sense of the world around us. How we fall for misinformation, stereotypes, and just plain irrational thinking. The book is very well written and very readable. Yes, we have a pit bull in our family. We've been dog owners for over 30 years and have owned a wide variety of different "breeds" of dogs. The pit bull is the best.

Fabulous overview of the Western cultural history of these magnificent pets. Unbelievable depth and honesty showing both sides of the story. I got it from the library and then bought it. It's really dense so I would read a bit, think about it and then go back to it. Very important in understanding how the media and misrepresentation of information can affect the lives of so many loving creatures. My next dog is definitely a pit.

As a licensed veterinary technician for 20+ years, I've read ALOT of books regarding dogs, behavior, etc. This book hooked me instantly. The history of the breed, the present day struggles and triumphs. This was well written, fact based, and stayed on point. I highly recommend this book to anyone and everyone.

Thoughtful, objective well written. Hopefully will help show the world how delightful these dogs are. Sadly they are much maligned and frequently abused, tortured, abandoned and killed. Don't judge a book (read: dog) by it's cover. Make Michael Vick spend some time in prison.

Comprehensive look at the history of all -- not just Pit Bull -- breeds. Honest and fair depiction of this much maligned breed.

This book is great! The author really does a good job of breaking down the entire history of the dog and how it has evolved over time. I especially like all the details on studies that have been done on this breed, really puts the battle over breed into perspective. A great read for any dog advocate, pit bull specific or not.

Well-written, extremely well-researched book with many interesting facts, insights, anecdotes, etc. The references are extensive and well-explained. A must for any dog lover, or trainer.

I learned a lot about dogs and pit bulls from this book. By showing us the people behind the dogs, the author helps us understand why pibbles are so hated by so many.

Though the beginning is very sad, this book is a real eye opener of where Pit Bulls have come from, where they went and their come back. From bad information passed off as facts to the great rescue groups showing the world what these amazing dogs are truly like. A great read/listening.

For anyone interested in these dogs, I would highly recommend this book. A fascinating look at their history and how the media's inflammatory rhetoric contributes to the way some people view pit bulls. Highly recommended, a pit bull owner whose boy has coexisted peacefully with a Dachshund, Husky, Lab, and Great Dane for over 12 years.

Every person who rescues companion animals needs to read this book. I believe that rescued pitties are the best species on the planet after reading this book.

Great book!

Filled with lots of history and in-depth information. Sometimes dry but great information. I love my pit!!!!

Great book so far I don't like that the author decided to use some fiction and actual true stories about the history of the breed and what they went through I would just rather hear honest facts and stories I don't think you need to add fiction to it just to make your book sound more interesting so people will buy it so it doesn't sound so plain just be honest 100%

Have been doing shelter volunteering for a few year and always heard the stories of pit bulls only to find them friendly and easy to train. Having adopted a mix breed of who knows what origin but who was listed as a pit mix what more info and this book looks at the subject in depth.

She gives great info on the history of dog breeds, how quickly interbreeding can change characteristics, and the history of prejudice against multiple breeds throughout history.

Bronwen Dickey is an excellent writer, like her brother. Recommended reading for all dog lovers.

Focus on the dogs please. I agree with her conclusion though. On the dogs, that is.

This is by far the most detailed and best researched book I've read on Pit Bulls, my favorite type of dog ever since I began walking dogs at the shelter as a volunteer. I'm only half way into it, but already am eager to recommend it to friends and fellow volunteers.

The most comprehensive and fact-checked source of information about the TRUTH of "pit bulls." All of the urban myths are put to the test with cited resources.

Great book. The author really did her research. It’s got lots of information. Not exactly a page turner but not boring like a textbook.

If you have an opinion on pit bulls one way or the other, you really need to read this book. It’s a very fair book at a very complicated situation. It speaks to moral panics and social outrage. It is truly a book from times.

I like the "Pit Bulls & Parolees" TV show and wanted to learn more. It was interesting and nicely written. prompt delivery and no problems.

The book ‘Pit Bull – The Battle Over an American Icon’ by Bronwen Dickey is an excellent historical and scientific review of the controversy surrounding the American pit bull terrier in The United States (and abroad). The information that she presents in this book is clear, concise and very well researched. At the same time, though it contains large quantities of research, it remains very approachable which is always a tough balance for an author to find. This book is the rare example of something fun to read and informative. The book includes a few chapters discussing the history and cultural evolution of the APBT and other associated breeds. It talks about both the societal approaches to breed development in dogs and the societal response to various dog breeds. Mrs. Dickey draws wonderful comparisons to the evolution of society and how it (in some cases) is reflected in our approach to pets. There is a lot in there that was brand new to me, and Mrs. Dickey provides ample examples and compelling narratives to describe these connections and relationships. She also includes interviews with many people who have been involved with pit bulls, on both sides of the debate and those add a lot to these discussion. The book also digs deep into the science behind the cultural response to the pit bull, as well as the impacts of breed specific legislation. This was particularly interesting. Mrs. Dickey does an excellent job of explaining the sparse data that exists to truly evaluate dog bite specifics, and the way much of the media has misrepresented what these statistics truly say. In one chapter, she does an excellent job of showing a false narrative can be created when scientists who are not in a particular field can misunderstand data and present it in a way to cause catastrophic and misinformed media response. This, in turn, can lead to societal fear, myth spreading and in its worst case misinformed policy development (both within the animal control arena and legislative process). Mrs. Dickey explains this in a way that is easy to understand. Her chapter discussing this could easily be applied to many other anti-science arenas, in fact. This chapter alone is well worth the read and I plan to use it in two of my classes this coming year when discussing public health communication. As an epidemiologist, I am incredibly impressed with how well she describes the research and it's impact on the media and policy folks. In addition, early in the book she does a great job in explaining what a dog breed really is and how difficult it is to label and assess dogs based on this delineation. Overall, this book is wonderfully done. I could not recommend it more fully. I am so impressed with Mrs. Dickey’s ability to both tell a compelling story and give an informed analysis of an important scientific and policy driving issue. Thank you so much for writing this book!

Wonderful historical review of the Pit Bull and how we got here. For anyone wanting to understand the emotion over these dogs this is a good read. They are wonderful animals who unfortunately have been villified due to human actions.

This book is incredibly well-researched and thorough. it touches on many areas of the history of pit bulls over the years, how the variations of the breed developed, the real facts behind some of the "incidents" that led to knee-jerk reactions of BSL and overall fear, and how numerous people with real knowledge of the breed got involved with them. I can completely see why this book took years to research and write. It is loaded with real information and thoughtful analysis. I took longer to read this book than I usually take to finish a book of similar size, because I had to let it all soak in. I made notes in my Kindle, which I have never done before with a book. There is so much in here I want to remember and retrieve later. I admire the author a great deal for taking on a controversial subject and sticking to her principles and more importantly sticking to truth and facts. I'd love to meet her and tell her so in person.

Very interesting and informative, not only about pit bulls, but the history and evolution Of all dogs.

Oh this is a really good book for pittie lovers. Although I must say I love my pittie, my jack russell mix, and Brussels griffons all the same .

I listened to Ms. Dickey's interview on NPR and ordered her book within a few days. I read the reviews on Amazon and suggested to a friend that she might like it. She wasn't interested and based her opinion on some of the negative reviews that began to appear on Amazon. I read the latest reviews again and was surprised at the nastiness and misinformation they contained. It was clear to me most hadn't even read the book, and were driven by some sort of viscousness against the author. I received my copy and found it to be one of the best books I've read in some time. The author helps the reader through hyperbole and hidden agendas and pseudoscience by citing evidence that is verifiable. Her research is thorough and well-sourced, and her interviews are thoughtful and unbiased. She is gifted, insightful, and her writing addresses uncomfortable truths about us and our dogs. We all bear some responsibility for the profiling of dogs and their humans, the misinformation and myth, and the behavioral projection and anthropomorphism that has created the plight suffered by certain breeds. Ms. Dickey's book is a valuable tool that reminds us all to not be swayed by rumor and fear mongering, but to seek out legitimate and rigorous resources in challenging our biases.

I love this book. I love pit bulls and I love how this book portrays them. It doesn't paint them as the world's best dog and every family should have one (because anyone who loves dogs knows that not every dog is right for every person and certainly not vice versa). It just paints them as what they are, DOGS. Very well researched and easy to read and understand.

I have always wanted to know the history of the bully breeds ever since I became a pit bull owner. This book is both heart warming and heart wrenching at the same time. These dogs are amazing and have had such an impact throughout history. Great book!

Love this book. It gets to the heart of what a pit bull is or isn't.

Great book that looks at why not just put bulls but why any dog can become the a fictional boogie man

This is by far the best and most complete examination of the breed to date. Everyone buy it!

A very well researched and written book. The author presents a fair and accurate description of Pit Bulls and Pit mixes and the attitudes surrounding them. I would encourage people to read this book before writing negative reviews. My rescued Staffordshire Bull Terrier is loyal, courageous, intelligent and affectionate. As a matter of fact this breed was commonly refrred to as the Nanny Dog in the late 19th century because of their unparralled love and devotion to childrren. Pit Bulls have been tragically betrayed by abusive owners and further villified by the critics. Thank you, Ms. Dickey, for trying to set it straight.

Great book, presented with facts and an unbiased opinion

This is a great in depth and informative book about one of the most popular breeds. Quick read and very enjoyable!

I have a grandbaby pitbull. This book helps me to understand her. She is a sweetie, I love her.

I used this book for a Persuasive Speech I did for school, it was full of helpful information and really helped me understand the miscommunication we have with this breed. Good book highly recommend

As a proud APBT owner, it was nice to read about how this misunderstood breed was once the most popular breed in America. Indeed, it represented America on WWI era posters. Among the famous owners, Teddy Roosevelt, Woodrow Wilson and Helen Keller!

One of the best books i've ever read. Truly a remarkable book about this breed, and more importantly, human beings.

One of the best books of the year! Well researched, well written and easy to get caught up in. Thank you to Bronwen Dickey for the best book on pit bulls I've ever read!

Very well written and researched.

This book is an excellent and factually accurate telling of the history of the pit bull breed in America. It's unfortunate that exactly the people who should become educated about pit bulls refuse to do so; they miss out on some of the best American hero stories ever told! For example, the pit bull called Sergeant Stubby was a WWI hero who saved numerous Allied troops and held at least one German soldier until he was taken into custody. Then there is Popsicle, a pit bull who was pulled out of a drug dealers' freezer, who went on to score one of the biggest drug busts in Texas and ranks as the #1 dog in US Customs. Unfortunately, America is becoming a place where facts are not relevant and reality appears to be mutable. Sadly, dogs cannot choose that mindset. You and I are the ones who can make a difference for these dogs; instead of maligning them, let's work on increasing access to spaying/neutering clinics, obedience classes, and fun sports like flyball! Pit bulls LOVE flyball!!

This was and fascinating book. It is about so much more than dogs or pit bulls--the media, poverty, racism. I thoroughly enjoyed it and learned a lot about dog behavior and people behavior.

Excellent book. Covers many myths about Pit Bulls and both sides of the controversy.

I'm a strong Bully breed advocate, and this book really gives good details and such about this misunderstood breed.

For pit bull lovers & dog lovers in general; A great read.

Great book, came quickly, one satisfied customer.

Never thought a book could completely change my opinion about pit bulls. This book did it.

Very good book. We have an American Staffordshire Terrior. He's a blessing. I love my Audible Books and this is a good one.

A great book to educate, entertain and inform about the breed.

A thoughtful and well-researched body of writing that reads like a story book. Beautiful in its prose. Meticulous in its examination. Bravo!

Very informative and well written book.

Great book and resource. The author takes an unbiased approach and is very professional and utilizes a variety of resources and research methods. Very well written and cited.

An easy read and great information. It will help my advocacy for Pit Bulls.

Family members own 3 pibbies, and love the book

I love this book

The book for information about this dog.

Bronwen Dickey perfectly intersects the story of this breed with the history of racial bias and oppression in the United States. 'Pit Bull' is artfully written and well researched.

Well written. I am an advocate for these dogs and it was how society were generalizing Pit Bulls to be bad with no scientist evidence. Very sad actually.

Goes straight to my heart. I rescued a beautiful pittie, Alana, from a shelter. Now working on finding her a forever home. She is another perfect ambassador of her breed. Please visit Facebook.com/savingalana

I learned so much. It was so interesting.

Great book..my daughter watches a bunch of Pit Bulls and after I read it I thought she should have it..

The book is an interesting historical perspective on how we got where we are with "pit bull" type dogs. The author seems to be fair in her assessment of the history and how both lovers and haters of these dogs can be extreme. She really did her research and i think it shows in the pages. A well written good read.

Everyone afraid of Pitfalls (or loving them) should read this. It's very educational but interesting written.

So far is great

Best APBT book in 20 years

This is a thoughtful book that looks at a flashpoint topic - pit bulls in America. The author looks at the history of these dogs, as well as the authenticity of the documented pitbull attacks. Anyone involved with animal rescue or dogs in general should read this, but especially those who fear pitbulls or love pitbulls.

For Pitbull lovers and dog owners alike. The author does a fantastic job of using actual evidence and science to talk about dogs, dog breeds, and aggressiveness. Presents a fantastic history of the history of dogs and the history of dog breeding, and gets actual scientific evidence about dog bites, dog aggression, and humans being killed by dogs. This book should be required reading for anyone who owns a dog, pitbull or not.

Good story. We have a pit, good dog

very informative

Highly recommended. Dickey thoroughly combs through the multi-decade debate to pull out scientifically rigorous studies, and helps to highlight the shoddy and at times outright falsified pseudo-science that informed many anti-pitbull groups and advocates. Her interviews with the many people involved are fascinating, as is her full historical tracing of the breed. About time somebody combed through and pull out the facts.

Excellent read to gain a better understanding of the history and culture surrounding pit bulls.

Definitely one of the most interesting books I have ever read!! Not just talking about the history of the pit bull, but the breeding of dogs and the roll they play in our lives

Fantastically well researched and well written. Highly recommend to any animal lover.

Insightful, well-researched, well written. I can't recommend this enough for anyone who has been affected by this ongoing debate.

This was the best book I have read about the breed and I have read them all!

Great book so far! It's worth the purchase.

Loved it. Very informative.

great product.

heartbreaking and inspiring account of the country's (world's?) most misunderstood yet most loving breeds of dog.

This is a well-written and well-researched book. Even though I thought I knew a great deal about pit bulls, I learned even more from this excellent book.

As a proud pibble rescue owner, a great read, although at times the stories about small-minded idiots who only believe the media and don't get to know this wonderful breed firsthand (something I personally experience too often) angered me. A good, worthwhile read. Thank you Bronwen for doing the research and writing a good tome.

This is one of the BEST books I've ever read. It's written in such a way to keep you interested throughout, because she never gets held up on one point for too long. It makes you angry, sad, and then motivated to be a voice for these incredibly misunderstood dogs. I HIGHLY recommend this book to everyone - especially if you are afraid of "Pitt Bulls"...

Fantastic book, well researched and unbiased. Dickey takes the time to investigate this inflammatory topic, including the history, stigma, and tragic consequences of ignorance and fear. Highly recommend for lovers of the breed, haters, and anyone in between.

I can't recommend this book enough. If is very well written and researched. The author's insights into humans are every bit as insightful and thought provoking as her comments on a misunderstood breed of dog. The book does leave me despairing for not only these beautiful creatures but mankind. Her book was a commentary about our prejudices, rush to judgements, rejection of science, the manipulation of statistics, man's follies at best and stark cruelty at worst. An excellent book. I hope all it gets a readership beyond just pit bull lovers.

This is must read book to get well-researched coverage of a clearly media misrepresented breed. Kudos to Ms. Dickey for allowing this breed to be just what it is---another dog.

Brings together information I learned from reading "The Pitbull Placebo" by Karen Delise along with further historical research. I could never quite understand what went so horribly wrong for these wonderful dogs. The context of social upheaval, poverty, race issues, and the woefully inadequate educational level of our elected officials gives a better understanding. I hope that this book can help in the continuing effort to end Breed Specific Legislation.

This book is a must read if you are a pitbull owner, especially if you are working to end breed specific legislation. Painstakingly researched over 7 years and eloquently written, "Pitbull" examines the social, cultural, and economic forces that have combined to influence public perception of pitbulls throughout the world.

love this book. so interesting the depth she goes into to tell the story about why things like this happen to people and animals. so much than a book about the Pitty.

Absolutely fantastic book. I'm in the humane movement - mostly with cats. Very insightful book - they are just dogs!!!

So far the writer has done an amazing job of compiling information. She as far as I see is a very good writer. At first I bought the book because she was getting a bad rap and being treated aweful by a few of the anti Pit bull people..

Meticulously researched, and clearly explained. Kudos to the author for seeing through the racism! Great dogs, caught up in a "war" that wasn't their fault...

What a great book! Highly recommended!

This is a fabulous book, completely fact driven, meticulously researched, unsentimental. This woman traveled the length and breadth of the country, interviewing people on both sides of the matter. It was hard to read. So much cruelty. It is hard to fathom the disasters that have overcome this wonderful breed in latter years, transforming them from beloved and prized family and working dogs into objects of hatred. It's heartbreaking

This meticulously researched, compulsively readable, and occasionally devastating book should be required reading for anyone interested in pit bulls, dogs, American history, race, media studies, and rhetoric. An outstanding accomplishment.

A study of fear mongering in the world today and the ramifications for man's best friend. A must read.

One of the best books I've read. Ms. Dickey provides a well-researched, thoughtful read that examines all aspects of America's pit bull obsession, including historical, genetic, scientific, cultural, and sociological aspects.

Loved it! Very insightful. Easy to understand.

A must read! They have been wrongly crucified for their loyalties to humans. A breed that will love you unconditionally & will also protect you, no matter what. As long as they are trained (as with any breed) they are great loving family member.

I'm grateful Bronwen Dickey took the time, did the research, and told the story of these dogs from a historical perspective. I felt as though, finally, I could gain an understanding of them and how their story became so notorious without having to navigate through and decipher myths.

Great book. Really helps put into perspective the situation with this misunderstood animal. Author offers her references to the sources used to base your perspective.

Great book - well-written, well researched. Facts presented.

Goes beyond the history of the pit by dealing with race and class issues in America. Very eye opening and a good read. Has some amazing historical pictures.

This is a great book! Everyone should read it!

Exhaustive research went into this very complete work on our favorite breed.

Loved every page in this book.

Loved this book. Well written and researched.

Well written, objective and compassionate

Very well written, I had hoped it would include a lot more on pitbull personality, training tips, breed characteristics, etc. But overall a very good read.

A well written history of what used to be called "America's dog" and "the nanny dog." The author debunks the many misconceptions about this, and other, Bully breeds. I've had 2 American Staffordshire Terriers (AmStaffs), which are often mis-classified as Pit Bulls, one male and one female, who were the sweetest, most loving and loyal dogs I've had, save for my Dobermans. My female was canine-aggressive, but super sweet and patient with adults and children.

Much needed book to help understand these great dogs.

I learned so much about the history of pit bulls. Great read.

Beautiful quality book. Haven't read it all yet, but so far I love it.

A very well researched and written book. I enjoyed reading about PFL (Pets for Life) and the good work they do. I wish there was more focus on the recent reality television shows that have highlighted the plight of pit bulls (and dogs in general) and their abilities. There was only a passing reference to Pit Bulls and Parolees and nothing on Ceasar Millan, whose dog Daddy was one of the best pit bull ambassadors ever seen on TV. These shows (along with my own research) helped me overcome the negative stereotypes that have tarnished the reputation of these dogs and gave me the confidence to adopt a pit bull mix two years ago - one of the smartest and most loyal dogs I've every had.

Amazing! It was so awesome to read about this wonderful bread from the history of America's dog to the sad down fall by humans forcing these dogs to fight. They are not "hard wired" to fight like dogbite.org says. If you have half a brain you are able to see that DBO is nothing more than a fear mongering, pitbull hating site producing their pseudoscience information. Being a nurse I prefer scientific evidence based research. I figured this part out even before reading your book. You book was very informative, I learned a lot ant was actually able to get our BDL repealed in my city after presenting the with facts from reputable Animal welfare organization like Bestfriends.org, the Humane society even used some info from your book. So thank you for helping us be the voice for the voiceless.

Note that a raft of one-star "reviews" showed up within hours of the book's publication. These people were sent over from an anti-pit-bull hate group on Facebook, which is urging its members to "swarm" Amazon. They have NOT read Bronwen Dickey's book. The Facebook page is explicit: "Here's the deal: We don't need to read it to understand the book's underlying theme." Well, here's the real deal: you DO have to read it. That's how books work. If you haven't actually read something -- carefully -- then no: you are not in a position to understand anything about it. Much less review it. I received an electronic galley a couple of weeks ago, and read it with joy. I assure you that it's by far the most careful and rigorous treatment of the subject to date; it's also an undeniable work of literature -- a gift to the genre -- and genuinely entertaining. I wonder whether any of the kindhearted people leaving fake reviews will ever get around to glancing at the book itself. Apart from everything else, they might be disappointed by how evenhanded the work is: Ms. Dickey spends a fair bit of time with voices on both sides of the pit-bull debate. Her own conclusions favor science -- she doesn't side with the extremists (who can be found, unfortunately, in both camps). It's a thorough, level-headed and intelligent treatment of a fraught topic; I expect it will remain the definitive work for some time. ----------------------------------- Note: the hate group has just changed its name -- they used to call themselves "Pit Bulls and Amputees." They're now hiding behind the innocuous title, "Pit Bull Public Safety Education and Advocacy." Their campaign of harassment against Ms. Dickey has been documented by the press, however, and it makes for ugly reading: do a search on "Pit bull author’s critics are off the leash," by Josh Shaffer (The News & Observer). Also note: I have nothing whatsoever to do with any sort of "right wing, pro-pit bull group" -- the libel posted below. This is the kind of tactic that Ms. Dickey is encountering: ad hominem lies, conjured from thin air.

You will read some comments promoting fear, hatred and ignorance toward pit bulls because of a bad personal experience or because one believes the media monster dog fabrication that is not a true reflection of this dog. The majority of these dogs live in stable family environments. It is interesting to note that these self-proclaimed "dog experts" conveniently leave out other breeds of dogs that attack, maim and kill. These folks are not interested in public safety or protecting anyone or anything. Their sole purpose is to malign and exterminate an entire class of dog based on personal hatred. The arguments the anti-pit bull cult present are nonsensical, lack any real empirical evidence to support their bogus claims, believe in conspiracy theories, ticking time bombs, and also believe in a “dog fighting industry” that financially supports organizations that do actual canine research. How realistic is that? There is not one professional canine behavior organization that supports the anti-pit bull groups' stance on pit bulls. I encourage anyone looking for an honest assessment of the pit bull experience to read Bronwen Dickeys new book "The Pit Bull: The Battle Over An American Icon". Don't trust one star reviews from prejudiced and demented people that did not even buy, much less read, the book. Don't believe the media hype or the proponents of irrational fear.

Great book - it's about time someone wrote a balanced, thoroughly investigated approach to the Pit Bull dog -- how it has become so vilified, and why so many people love this misunderstood dog. This is for people who love Pits as well as people who would like to know more about them -- as well as dog lovers in general. I would like to think that Pit-haters will also read this book, but I doubt they will since they are ignorant and don't want to be educated.

Enjoyable history and anecdotes about one of our most loved dogs!

I truly believe this book should be required reading for everyone. The amount of research, time and consideration that went into creating this work is just staggering. Ms. Dickey was set on the course of crafting this book by the reactions of people around her when she adopted her "pit bull," Nola. What follows is a thorough, insightful look into a number of questions: - What, really, is a pit bull? - What is its history? - Where do stereotypes against dog breeds come from? - Does science back up any of the wild claims of pit bulls being dangerous? This isn't a gushing, "Pit bulls are the BEST dogs, the ONLY dogs, the BE ALL END ALL of dogs" book. This is a critical study of a maligned group of dogs and how they have come to be viewed by our society. Not only that, but she addresses socioeconomic and class issues amongst humans and draws connections between how we treat the dogs and how we treat each other. I'm guessing Ms. Dickey doesn't read Amazon comments (probably a good thought, considering the absurd posters on here), but if she does - thank you, Ms. Dickey. Thank you for working so hard to create this book and give a holistic look at the pit bull.

It's interesting to note that the one star reviews, to date at least, are not "verified purchases," especially considering that the book is so new. It's shameful to attack something that you didn't at least make a passing attempt to understand. On the book itself, I have purchased it, and read it. It is thoroughly enjoyable and takes as even-handed approach as is likely possible on this subject. It is factual and well researched, while avoiding being a dry "peer reviewed journal" tome. It was definitely worth the price, and the time invested in reading it.

Fantastically well-researched, this book examines and explains the history of dogs in America - both under the "pit bull" umbrella and not. Through a historical and sociological lens from the beginning of America through today, this is a fascinating journey with deep insight and compassion for all parties. The author strikes a very delicate balance threading the line between the sides to illuminate a whole that is larger than breed: all dogs are dogs. The chapter on genetics and dilution of breed characteristics over generations is very well-explained. I plan to point people to this explanation in the future. Really, I can't say enough good things about this book. I bought the book after reading two excerpts because of how thought-provoking they were, and then devoured the book in one sitting because I couldn't pull myself away. Investigative journalism at its finest - a culmination of years of research plus a thorough list of sources.

Thought it would glaze over the history and be the same old, same old pit bull book. This is a GREAT book.

Great research/- a real education on the subject

I currently own and foster pit bulls, and truly love the breed. I couldn't wait to buy this book, but I'm around halfway through, I'm having a hard time plodding along, as the author is making a point to run through all the other breeds that were vilified in their day...and Ive owned some of those breeds too. I don't think spreading hate for other breeds is the right avenue. I think the author is trying to level the playing field, BUT the statistics I don't doubt are true, don't leave anyone better off. Dogs are dogs to me, and they all deserve love, respect, and obedience. I commend her efforts to revive the love and affection Americans in particular once had for the breed, but I can see how people who hate the breed could jump all over this as fact tweaking. She does make some flippant comparisons that seem a bit coarse. I loved the chapters about breeding and genetics, and different ways to view some of the sloppy statistics that have been misinforming the public, but I'm hoping we get more heartfelt stories with positive information instead of another 8 chapters of her explaining how/why everyone else got it wrong. I'd say it's a step in the right direction, but perhaps her heart is TOO deep in the subject to be fair and unbiased. I finished the book, and got more of the people and positive support anecdotes I wanted to read about, rather than statistics, in regards to rescues and outreach programs in the last 3-4 chapters. One of the ideas that stuck with me was that the best thing that could happen for these dogs would be for people to stop talking about them.

Excellent book about the history of the bully bread. A bit tedious to get through. Interesting nevertheless.

Well researched and well written

Lots of good information

An incredibly well written book that is really hard to read in places because it is so matter of fact. Thank you Bronwen Dickey for stating so clearly what many of us have thought when we read about the cases you have highlighted in your book.

Very well written history of the "pit bull" , and dog, in American in general. Interesting conclusions drawn between different cultural phenomenon and the rise of breed popularity and breed-specific legislation. The author tries to give space for all sides of the story to voice their opinions, and it creates an encompassing narrative. Any dog lover needs to read this book!

Well written and well researched. An excellent and informative read for anyone interested in dogs or psychosocial, class, and racial issues

I've read a lot about pit bulls and other dog breeds as well. I found this book thoughtful and incredible and recommend everyone, especially the people that think negatively of the breed, to read the book before judging the breed or the book itself. Not all pit bulls are bad and you can't lump every single one of them into the dangerous category. I've had many breeds of dogs in my life and I've had friends and family members that have had every breed out there, and there are just as many dogs of other breeds that can be aggressive. But, I'm not here to debate the breed, I'm here to talk about the book because that's what we're reviewing. However you feel about the breed, the book is a wonderful read and I highly recommend it.

There have been dozens of books written about "pit bulls". Most are boilerplate breed overviews or thinly veiled apologies for dogfighting. This new one, like Diane Jessup's THE WORKING PIT BULL, blazes new ground for the public in understanding what the real American pit bull is about .. and what it's NOT about. As Jessup's book highlighted the many capabilities of the original American dog beyond its original role (which despite the few miscreant remnants who make the headlines, was abandoned long ago by breed fanciers), Dickey's book brilliantly covers the social milieu that has made the dog an avatar for many prejudices that have nothing to do with dogs. In today's world, "pit bull" no longer means only the American pit bull terrier, one of the first recognized American breeds... but anything that has a square head and short hair. Or to put it the other way round, if a dog bites, it's a "pit bull", whatever it looks like and whatever breeds may have gone into it. Why is it that only dog bites that involve a dog that can be called a "pit bull" make it into the newspaper headlines? Why do people believe "pit bulls" are uniquely dangerous (despite the actual evidence)? Dickey's is the first book to lay out the historical/sociological explanation. It's a "must read" for dog lovers as well as sociologists.

This book really captures what makes pit bulls such a fascinating subject for a writer--it isn't just their long and varied history, but more so the way they have been used, abused and mythologized by the people who love and hate them. They are the equivalent of a Rorschach ink blot--what people see in them says more about people than it does about the dog. But Dickey backs everything up with science, which has the aggressively unscientific haters in a tizzy. (No matter, they share their opinions without bothering to read.) My favorite pages are the ones that reveal the head of Dogsbite.org to be a literal stone-throwing astrologer, and her comrade Merritt Clifton a hack with phony credentials. (His 100 peer reviewed studies don't actually exist.) And yet, these are the sources the critics continue to site in their negative reviews.

This book is a stellar example of putting lipstick on the proverbial pig. Pitbull Priestess Jane Berkey, who is gushingly profiled here, has blood on her hands for helping to send so many fighting breed dogs for adoption to unsuspecting homes. The majority of the fatal attacks by pits and their mixes are now on women and children. I am seeing so many girls and women walking their pits now and homeless people always have them. I resent having to feel afraid of an unprovoked attack by one of these things when I walk anywhere. Before 1980 these things were rare, now, thanks to Berkey and friends they are everywhere, frequently unfixed and dangerous.

Good in

Great book. Very well written. This book is full of facts and very useful information. I highly recommend this book to everyone.

Bronwen Dickey's new book "Pit Bull: The Battle over an American icon" was so thoroughly researched, I can't give it enough praise. You don't even have to like dogs to enjoy this book. Bronwen spent 7 years researching the relationship between humans and canines. It's all here and contains pages of citations to back up everything she's said. Studies, dogs, people, communities, the media fear-mongering and statistics. If you are looking for an excellent book that will keep you captivated, please pick this one up. Never mind the one star reviews, unfortunately, they are members of an anti-pit bull hate group on the internet who have publicly announced they will be sabotaging reviews. Why would you sabotage a book you haven't read? Especially one that is full of actual science equip with facts? This isn't about pro-pit bull, this is about dogs and educating the public about dogs as individuals. If anything, the hate groups are helping promote this book, because Miss Dickey has done an exceptional job. It takes a special book to keep me reading until 2AM, this was it. Please review the book once you've read it, this will hopefully change the minds of those who are willing to learn about dogs and maybe some who've been pressured by fear of the unknown. You know longer need to fear when all the answers are in this book. As Bronwen quoted, "After all we have put them through, maybe it is time to let pit bulls show us who they are, to let them have a part in writing their own story. Pit bulls are not dogs with an asterisk. Pit bulls are just...dogs." You will be amazed, shocked, and hopeful once you're through with this. I have nothing but respect for this woman for all the work she has done. Enjoy!

First, the pit bull was NEVER an 'American Icon'. Even today pit bulls account for no more than 6% of the total US dog population while year after year committing over 60% of the FATAL attacks on people (fatalpitbullattacks.com) and 90% of the FATAL attacks on other animals in spit of 'how they're raised'. Helen Keller owned a Boston Terrier (a pit fighting dog at the time) not a pit bull (occupymaulstreet.blogspot.com). Teddy Roosevelt's pit was know for attacking the French Ambassador. Too bad pit owners don't 'get educated' like they tell everyone else to.

Very detailed, sometimes too much. Pictures and history good.

Fantastic. Totally worth a read if you've ever fallen into the lazy trap of stereotyping dogs based on their appearance. The logic and data the writer uses is clear and to the point - we should celebrate a truly American breed of dog, not vilify them!

I was extremely disappointed to find that this book is not about Pitbull. Pitbull is absolutely an American icon, and he has come to represent a myriad of different things to different people. From an underground gangster rapper scraping together financing for his early work, to becoming an internationally recognized pop icon, his authenticity has perpetually been under the microscope. He symbolizes prosperity, vapid pop, multiethnic inclusion, transethnic art, selling out, living authentically, and so much more. But no, this book is about some stupid dogs.

Fantastic. Well written and extremely well researched. It's not just a book about how a breed became unfairly demonized, but even more generally, how many people have become too dependent on emotion, instead of facts and rationality, to guide their thinking. When she pokes holes all through the arguments of the anti-pitbull crowd, they volley back not with facts but with ad hominem attacks against her. The only "facts" they can conjure are from disreputable sources or extremely isolated, anecdotal incidents. Hopefully this book will do something to turn the tide against these great dogs.

Exceeded expectations ! A must read for those who already love bully breeds and those who may want to know more about these widely discriminated against dogs. So much prejudice and media hype as well as Mis -information gets into people's heads sometimes that they can't use proper judgement. Dickey touches on that in the first 5 pages of this book. All dogs are individual and should be judged individually, that's a fact you can count on.

Outstanding reading. Pulls the data that has been compiled by the leading researchers and historians in the area of animal behavior and puts in into one book. Explains our long history with our closest animal companions and nthe eeds they have filled in our lives. Attempts are made to have all sides of the discussions represented. Like the topic itself the book should be read and then an opinion can be made and not judged by its cover with conclusions made outside realm of science.

Not only is this a great book about Pit Bulls and their history, but dogs in general, behavior, breeding. The long history of fear and fear mongering surrounding many breeds of dogs based on little or false information is not only pertinent to dogs, but to so many things in our lives!

A fine job and a must-have for anyone who wants a fair and balanced overview of the pit bull matter and the parties involved from all sides to date. Worth every penny.

An extremely valuable contribution to the field of animal welfare, but perhaps even more essential as a treatise on moral panics and how we humans get ourselves worked up into a frenzy over issues that are not as big as we think they are. Bottom line: it ain't the dogs that are the problem here. Dickey writes clearly, vividly and with high regard for reason and science; if you're like me, you'll appreciate her measured tone and her refusal to stop at the easy answer. A book this carefully researched might have been boring, but the writing is just gorgeous, and the interviews with colorful characters make this a page-turning, pleasurable read. Another bonus is the wide-ranging, multi-disciplinary scope. She truly tackles the subject from every possible angle, and the result is that you come away feeling you've learned about much more than a type of dog. You can tell by the fervor of the comments here - Pit Bull is sure to start an impassioned national conversation that's well overdue.

I'm a professional dog trainer and have worked with thousands of dogs, many of which were bully breeds or what some might consider "pit bulls." I waited to read this book as I suspected it would be more of a text book on the breeding of dogs, the history of dogs, and the pro/con Pit camp. I hear the arguments every day and truly believe that Breed Specific Legislation (BSL) is BS. I just...let the book sit because I wasn't ready to be amped up. So it sat for a lot longer than it should have. This incredibly researched book goes way deeper than I could have imagined. It both enrages the reader and educates the reader. It has characters from all over the spectrum, well-intentioned people on every inch of the "pit bull" debate, and more. What I didn't expect but now can clearly see is how much of our darkest traumas as American's are entwined in this dog, the so-called "Pit bull" and the injustices that are undeniably a part of the controversy. Yes, the dogs are just dogs, but the name Pit Bull is more than a name . Pit bulls are American as apple pie. In the name, Pit bull is racism, is classism, is "you can't have what I have"ism, is the patriarchy, is anecdotal data trumping actual facts, is injustice - -and also the pit bull is hope..

Thorough, honest look at these noble beings

I'm not a huge non-fiction reader (give me a good crime thriller any day), but as an owner of a mix breed dog that we think may be part pit bull (along with lab and who knows what else) and given all the media blitz and comments bashing pit bulls, I felt obligated to read a book that helps to explain the story and bias of the "breed" What I found was not only a wonderful book about pit bulls, but also a book that makes you question a lot of what we see and hear in the media overall and to question what statistics. It is too bad so many people won't even come across this book unless looking for something as pit bulls, because the book also does an excellent job making you "think outside the box" about biases and information/statistics. As a dog lover, I also learned so much about the history of dogs over the past few centuries and how certain breeds came to rise in fall over time. It drives me crazy when someone bashes pit bulls based on few media stories alone. This is great book to learn about both sides of the debate, the history of the debate, and looking at biases overall and how to question why and where such biases stem. (as a warning, of course a story of pit bulls can't be presented without some tearful stories and accounts of dog fighting and abuse, but luckily, those stories are brief and don't make up the majority of the book). Note: for anyone with high school or college students, I would recommend they have their kids read this book purely for an example of how to write an excellent research paper.

Like many people throughout the world, my knowledge of pitbulls was framed by the media and various pseudo-facts spread by the internet, etc. Then, about 3 years ago, I started volunteering at a local shelter. From being cautious around the big block-headed pitty types that dominated the kennels, I grew to being a true fan of the very affectionate cuddly fun dogs I met. Having since done some of my own research, I understood that incorrect "breed" identification in dog bite cases and fatalities, along with media bias toward sensational coverage of such events in addition to their reporting of incorrect breed identification, was/is largely to blame for all the uproar about pits. However this book frames our current situation within the larger history of this breed group in the US and elsewhere. From their rise as treasured family pets, to their role in wars, their abuse as fighting and bull baiting dogs, to the racist undertones that have impacted these and other dogs during the past 200-300 years, this book is truly a tour de force. The book is based on science and citations are provided for each chapter. The book also prevents perspectives from many of the big names either pro- or against pitbulls, so I feel it is an objective work. Ultimately, I found it uplifting to hear about all the amazing people working to fight the unfound prejudices against these dogs. Kudos to Bronwen Dickey for the superb writing and research that went into this book.

An excellent, well-researched account of what is really going on in regards to Breed Specific Legislation and what is behind it. Everyone should read this.

I can't say enough about this book, which I read as an advance copy. The amount of research is Herculean, the attention to detail and accuracy something rarely seen these days, especially when we're talking about "pit bulls". As someone who has been involved in trying to repeal Ontario, Canada's provincewide breed ban for over a decade, I'm thrilled that this source of facts and evidence is now available. No more excuses. Ms Dickey's writing is compelling enough to make this book a real page-turner. I couldn't put it down. It talks about the dogs but more importantly in my view, it focuses on what we are actually doing when we strike at people - the poor, the minorities, the newcomers, the young - through something they love. It says more about us than it does about them. I am glad that the idea of banning shapes of dogs (since the majority are just loveable mutts) has been exposed for the racist, classist policy it actually is. If I could give this book more stars, I would. An excellent resource and a must-read for everyone with an interest in this issue.

I don't have a dog (I feel compelled to point out for some reason), but I do have an eye for insightful social scientific research and great writing. This book provides both and more. It is a must read for just about anyone interested in the cultural politics of stigmatization. This book is about how a dog with a general appearance has moved from family friend to maligned marauder based largely on media representation and public sentiment. Between the lines it is even a book about the social construction of criminality, trends in perspectives on class, and of course racialization. (I don't have a "verified purchase" stamp because I bought it through my work account... in case anyone thinks this is an insider review. It is not).

My only regret is that I let this sit on my wishlist for so long. This was a tremendous book to read and absorb. Yes, it is absolutely about Pit Bulls, but it expands well beyond and goes deep on the topic. The historical narrative of dogs that leads to pit bulls is worth learning about. How the relationship with humans remains roughly the same over hundreds of years but yet the relationship with society has shifted is also tremendous. Sadly, this also reinforced some bad things about society and sadly, the news media. Hurts a bit more considering the current state of the world. Still well worth buying and reading.

Do not buy. Unless you enjoy the deaths of people, dogs, cats, and other animals.

Meticulously researched, beautifully written. Facts, not emotions. You need to read this book......

This book is a very impressive piece of work. I cannot imagine how many hours went into its publication. If you are interested in how culture and news media mix, history, canine biology and genetics, social justice issues, humane society politics, or animal rights. I highly recommend this book. Its broad perspective and appeal cannot be understated. Three take home messages. Its very compelling how alike all dogs are. The history of the the dog in human life is that of service and submission, no matter the level of cruelty practiced by the humans and lastly, that social justice and animal welfare are 100% linked. I am thinking about class and pet ownership in a new way after listening to this book.

Okay, so full disclosure up front, I have not read the book yet but I feel that I want to say the following after I've read some of the reader comments. I promise to amend my comments once I've read the book. I am a volunteer dog walker at our local animal shelter where, as in many shelters across the country, the majority of dogs is pit bulls and Chihuahuas. At first, I was nervous walking, let alone entering the kennels of pit bulls to harness them up because I had been brainwashed into thinking these were inherently aggressive dogs, as I imagine many Americans have. Well, let me tell you about my experience. Like most of the dogs there, who are cooped up for 23 out of 24 hours in a 5 by 6 foot space, these dogs go nuts when a walker approaches. They jump up and down like yoyos. But it is not aggression, it is excitement! I take the dogs out, walk them for a while to let them get the first excitement at being outside out of their systems, then I sit down on a bench halfway through the loop walk, let the dogs sit next to me, feed them treats, stroke them gently, and talk to them softly for a while while. Many of them lean into me for closer physical contact. Some of them have licked my hands and some have licked my chin in one quick, affectionate slurp. I have lost every shred of fear of these dogs. They are exactly like any other dog, they love to be outside in the sun and move their bodies, they need to sniff things, they love a treat, they enjoy a calm, respectful touch, and they are grateful for it all. I see absolutely no difference in aggression level between pit bulls and other dogs. If you treat a dog well, the dog will turn out well. If you treat a dog badly, you will get an aggressive dog. But no dog is born "bad." That's a complete myth. Aggression in dogs serves very specific purposes. It almost never comes out of nowhere and for no reason. Now, on to the book! Addendum: Okay, I have now read the book. It is astonishingly well and thoroughly researched and contains a wealth of information. I found myself marveling at the huge amount of work that went into this book. It is also an amazingly entertaining read. In many ways, it is a history of America, racism, prejudice, and closed-mindedness as much as it is a history of how we have viewed dog breeds over time. It seems that there is always one vilified dog breed at any given time, be it the Spitz (!), the German Shepherd, the Rottweiler, or the Pitt Bull. The book also makes it abundantly clear that the reasons people get one dog over another may lead directly to bad dog behavior. A drug dealer who gets a pit bull to guard his stash of drugs will need an aggressive dog and will train his dog to be aggressive. Unfortunately, the myth of the inherently aggressive pit bull has soaked deeply into the collective national psyche. I had a conversation a few days ago with a group of friends, all of whom are generally very rational people, who trotted out the usual prejudices about pit bull's supposedly high force of bite, locking jaws, and inherently high levels of aggression. They could hardly believe my assertions regarding bite statistics, for example, and thought I was some sort of incredibly courageous person for walking pit bulls at the local animal shelter. But I am not. For one, I agree with the author that dog bites never come completely out of the blue. It's just that most of us don't bother to learn dog body language and miss many of the more subtle early warning signs that a dog is uncomfortable, like nose licking, looking away, and repeated yawning. So we barge into a dog's personal space and have no clue that the dog is not okay with it. Yes, there are probably some truly crazed dogs out there that will attack for no really good reasons but they are not confined to one breed. I highly recommend this book. It contains a wealth of information, is truly instructive, and a very fine read. To all the people with pit bull prejudices, I would like to say, don't talk about these dogs unless you have some direct experience of them. If you knew any pit bulls, you would know that they are not different from other dogs. Your venom says a lot more about you than about these dogs.